preview

The Wrong War at the Wrong Time for the Wrong Reasons in the Wrong Place

Better Essays

Why did American policymakers confuse nationalism with communism in Vietnam and try to superimpose a European model of the Cold War on to Southeast Asia? What was the rationale in taking the United States military halfway around the world and involve them in a 10 year unwinnable war? It seems almost a cliché, but it appears that the American policymakers could not see past 1917 and the Russian Revolution. The proud population of what we now call Vietnam had been struggling for many centuries, trying to throw off the yoke of foreign domination. It made little difference to them whether it was the Chinese from Asia are they French colonists from Europe, they preferred to rule their own country. The Four Power allies of World War II could …show more content…

As I alluded to earlier, the artificial border that created South Vietnam divided the agrarian South from the industrial North and sat up economic problems that rivaled those of the anti-bellum United States. Population groups were moved arbitrarily from one place to another. Families were divided and those members with questionable loyalties were executed. How do you instantly create loyalty to an artificially created power? About the only way that we have been able to do successfully in the United States has involved the building of a new high school and dividing the student population. Give them a new mascot, fight song, and "Saturday night lights", and after several years you will have a group of students who now detest their former alma mater. This is not as easy to accomplish within a country that has been struggling for over 1000 years to develop and maintain a separate identity. And certainly this cannot be easily accomplished by a foreign military power who does not understand the mindset of the Vietnamese. How could Dwight D. Eisenhower, the master commander of World War II, been led along the path toward defeat and humiliation? Did the actions of Martin Dies, Joe McCarthy, and his running mate Richard M. Nixon, helped to grease the skids that let our military hand-basket into hell? If Shirley Temple could be accused of having communistic sympathies, what hope was there for anyone in government? Therefore, Eisenhower's Republican

Get Access