preview

To What Extent Is John Proctor A Hero In The Crucible

Decent Essays

Mel S

The Crucible: Hero to Zero

In the 1953 play, The Crucible, John Proctor was portrayed as a fallen hero. Proctor was just an average farmer trying to support his family and make ends meet. He was tempted by a sweet 17 year old girl, or so she seemed; this girl was Abigail Williams. Abigail Williams was sweet and innocent in the eyes of Salem but infamous and cruel to those who knew the truth. She and other adolescent girls accused innocent people of practicing Witchcraft for selfish reasons and Abigail tempted John into having relations with her. John Proctor may have committed lechery but he was not a bad person. He had many flaws which resulted in his own downfall and reversed his fortune, but he indeed was killed for unjust purposes. …show more content…

Proctor was not wealthy but he did own a bit of land. He had two sons and a wife, Elizabeth Proctor. Everyone thought of John Proctor as a noble and wise man, but like Satan tempted Eve, Abigail tempted John. Thus Abigail believed John loved her even though his actions were out of lust. Abigail accused Elizabeth of Witchcraft, thinking she would be executed and she could take her place as Mrs. Proctor. Trying to get out of this new issue that emerged John has Mary Warren, a servant, confess to the court that she, Abigail and the other girls were pretending to be witched. Of course the girls turned on her and accused her of being a witch so she sided with them because she feared for her life so then John makes the mistake of saying “God is dead” which evokes a new …show more content…

None of the people hung during the trials deserved this harsh punishment. Abigail and the other girls claiming to have been witched were the ones dancing in the woods and practicing Voodoo not the townspeople or John. Proctor was hung because he made a statement that made the people think he was tied to Satan; “God is dead.” The only way John could have saved was himself was to admit to false accusations such as, he works for the devil and he to say he saw certain people with the Satan. John verbally claimed these indictments were true but Judge Danforth wanted it written. In writing it he would have lost his noble name and would have had to throw people under the bus and claim they were workers of Satan, causing them to lose their lives. John was imperfect but not a bad man. Reverend Hale wanted John to sign the contract and survive but John knew it was selfish and not the right thing to do. Instead of letting innocent people be punished wrongfully, John chose to pay the ultimate price and be hung. John did not deserve what he got, he never got to meet his unborn child, say goodbye to his sons one last time or live a normal life because of the selfishness of a few adolescent

Get Access