Critical Analysis of the Television Show Faking It
There is a general representation in the media of individuals of different genders, sexual orientation, and race that gives the audience a certain image of said group of individuals. Certain stereotypes have been engrained in our minds due to media which may reinforce certain issues such as racism, sexism, and homophobia. This essay gives an intersectional analysis on how the episode “Three to Tango” of the television show Faking It tries to represent diverse voices and identities but still falls under societal pressures of normalcy. First, I will introduce the articles that will be used as theoretical lenses which are Tricia Jenkins’ “’Potential Lesbians at Two O’clock’: The Heterosexualization of Lesbianism in the Recent Teen Film”, Kathleen Battles and Wendy Hilton-Morrow’s “Gay Characters in Conventional Spaces; Will and Grace and the Situation Comedy Genre”, Tony Coles’ “Negotiation the Field of Masculinity: The Production and Reproduction for Multiple Dominant Masculinities”, Laura Mulvey’s “Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema”, and Stuart Hall’s “The White of Their Eyes: Racist Ideologies and the Media.” These theories will be applied through sexuality to argue that, although
…show more content…
In this episode, there are two male characters, Pablo and Shane, who are can be argued to lack masculinity (“Three to Tango”). This is shown through the fact that they have been the characters chosen to be involved in a dancing competition. This gives the audience the idea that their sexual orientation is an influential reason as to why they have been selected to play in this part of the episode. Visibility isn’t necessarily positive, if it feeds to the general stereotypes that society presents (Battles and Hilton-Morrow
The Motion Picture Production Code, a method of censoring media, writes, “Sex perversion or any inference to it is forbidden” (g). While this code was only in effect from 1930 to 1968, the early attempt at censoring portrayals of LGBT characters has continued well into the present. LGBT characters are often represented negatively in the media, enforcing harmful stereotypes, or not represented at all. This topic is relevant because media portrayals of LGBT individuals impact how people view individuals in reality. By perpetuating negative stereotypes, the creators of media in force the belief that the lives of LGBT individuals are less important than non-LGBT people. In a time when people have virtually constant access to some form of media,
Ever since filmmakers started to explore the idea of focusing the story idea around ‘queer’ figures, people in society have been having mixed feelings about them. ‘Queer’ figures are basically people who are not within the male-female dichotomy. It is a term used to refer to homosexuals, transgenders and others who are unclear about their sexual preference. The queer film phenomenon was introduced in fall 1991 at Toronto’s Festival of Festivals, the best spot in North America for tracking new cinematic trends. (Rich 2013, Page 16) This got the ball rolling for more filmmakers to make films of different genres and subjectivity on this group of people. In this academic essay, the following thesis statement will be discussed – “The violence and
The representation of the LGBT community in the film industry has long been a topic of much debate. In her article, “It Ain’t Easy Being Bisexual on TV,” Amy Zimmerman addresses this topic with specific interest on bisexual representation. By appealing to the logic of her audience, using an informal tone, and referring to relatable content, Zimmerman constructs an argument which persuades readers of The Daily Beast that the film industry is unfairly and inaccurately representing bisexuals. However, her argument holds little influence over those who are not movie fans or The Daily Beast readers.
This approach to queer subtext has been has always been a part of Western media as we as we explored in the film “The Celluloid Closet” (1995). Queer representation for many years was an continuous uncategorized personification that was vaguely acknowledged but to those who understood the subtext, it became an undercurrent of complex coded information that eventually paved the way for the integration of queer identification within the hetero film storylines. Doty speaks about this and also mentions that at some point in time representation of queer culture and sexuality
In several cases, the desire to kill the queer self also occurs when it seems impossible to move forward without fully accepting and presenting oneself as queer. When this idea is seen on television it is presented in both the interpersonal and introspective forms. For example, the characters that attempt suicide, such as the eight queer women characters between 2001 and 2016, are illustrating the introspective act of assassinating the queer self by killing themselves. In contrast the interpersonal aspect derives from the idea of identity as zero-sum and therefore the queer characters who do not cover present a threat to the stability and validity of gay characters on screen. This paper will specifically investigate how the interpersonal side of "assassinating the queer selves" plays out on screen as a way to reinforce the importance of
In this paper, I will examine how women of color who deal with the lack of acceptance growing up because of their lesbianism help shape and/or will shape them to be future role models for LGBT people around the world. I will be using the coming of age drama, Pariah, directed and written by Dee Rees, as a primary source in order to argue how the cinematography in this film portrays Alike being the epitome of embracing one 's sexuality. I chose this film because it reminded me of a similar story that touched me in the form of a book written by Audre Lorde called Zami: A New Spelling of My Name. Standing up in what Alike believed in and taking a stand by fighting back against so many in the community deal with on a everyday basis is the driving force I will use to show how she took a big giant step
Before celebrating the strides of queer representation in all ages media, it is important to look back at queer representation in the past. The late film scholar Vito Russo painstakingly researched the evolution of queer representation in cinema in his landmark book The Celluloid Closet. In both the book and the documentary based of the book, Russo details the
Amy Zimmerman's position on the difficulties of bisexuality on TV presents an intriguing argument. However, Her use of pathos and ethos were rendered ineffective because of her select choice of audience and use of real-life examples.
While many believe that homosexuality has only been seen in mainstream media for only a few decades, it has actually been with America cinema since the early 1920’s. The portrayal of homosexuality in film and TV has come a very long way since the 1920’s. What viewers see on TV about homosexuality is really just a representation of America’s changing public view on the subject. While we have come to accept the topic of homosexuality in American society more willingly, we have substituted much of our prejudice about gays with the stereotypes that we see on TV constantly. Because as a society we are constantly forced to see these stereotypes, we are being halted in our progression to accept all different kinds of lifestyles.
In the comic series, Modern Family, the show depicts the lives of three families including interracial, homosexual and heterosexual families who all come together at the end of the day because of their love for one another despite their differences. Although the families are quite contrary views on various topics, the show successfully intertwines their lives allowing viewers to obtain a new perspective of family life from the show character’s point of view. In Jennifer Posner's excerpt, “Ghetto Bitches, China Dolls and Cha Cha Divas,” Posner explores how the media in particular the reality TV show, America’s Next Top Model, perpetuates stereotypes that are dangerous to well being of society. However, Posner’s reasoning fails to take into account the positive change
While this visibility does afford transvestites formal recognition, the presence of satire in their representation undermines their plight for recognition as a definition of gender expression and sexual identity (Hennessy, 2000). This, therefore, acts to police and regulate the social and cultural bodies of transvestite individuals within the neoliberal state. Therefore, men and women who show characteristics inconsistent with the neoliberal state's prescribed gender roles are often regulated and policed through the labelling of marginalized and different groups (Keyes, 2014). An autonomous, feminist and individualised woman often is subjected to ‘lesbian' labelling and this form of ‘othering' contributes to the regulation and individualised policing marginalized groups experience under the heteronormative, neoliberal state and its subsequent restrictions on gender and sexual identity (Keyes, 2014). However, the sex-gender matrix that operates under heterosexuality can often be understood in terms of the social struggle of queer visibility in the consumerist culture, to recognise not the form but the function of families in the homosexual sphere (Dnes,
Introducing an actual portrait of the five white Westmore men (Fig. 4) alongside prominent Civil Rights activists would effectively showcase the heterosexual framework the Westmore’s makeup art relies on. Tyburczy explains the motive of queer curatorship as a mode of revealing the “ways in which objects and bodies are made to relate to one another in space,” suggesting that the corporeal elements can easily be influenced through unconventional means (Tyburczy 199). The literal “queering” of the space and the introduction of underrepresented LGBT media unravels the social fabric and overlapping histories of the late 60’s and 70’s. Within the repetitive boundaries that Westmore and the curator implicitly enforced now become reversed with subjects that disrupt the rigid sexual identities of Hepburn and Stallone. Similarly, the physical “queering” of the space showcases media that interrupts the normal flow of familiar arrangements. Placing a circular display in the middle of underrepresented communities would inevitably force bodies to walk around the entire display and confront the discrepancy of representation in 60’s media. Accordingly, the placement of TV screens showing queer people of color constructs a new framework that ignores hegemonic rules set by mainstream media. Overall,
Heteronormativity is when heterosexuality believed to be the only natural norm in our society for sexual orientation. “New Girl”, an American sitcom, aired in 2011 on Fox, follows Jess (Zooey Deschanel) as she lives in a loft in Los Angeles with three men she meets on Craigslist. The second episode of the second season is what will be focused on in this essay. During which Jess meets a stranger when he accidentally mistakes her for his blind date, Nick (Jake Johnson) believes he has met his future self, and Schmidt (Max Greenfield) tries to make a good impression on Winston’s (Lamorne Morris) mom and sister. The writers of “New Girl” follow basic gender roles within the story-lines of the television show. The show follows a heteronormative plot. Through examining “New Girl”, a viewer can see the issues arise when considering the portrayal of men and women in media, and heteronormativity in television shows.
In Jeff Erbach’s The Nature of Nicholas we witness a treatment of the queer or gay as Other. Indeed, the film takes on a very literal representation of what Diana Fuss calls “the homosexual as abject”. The implications of Fuss’ claim on The Nature of Nicholas, therefore, calls for an analysis of how the abject as non-normative is schematized, and used to negotiate the ontological boundaries between Self and Other. Indeed, Fuss’ claim in juxtaposition with the film’s diegesis, produces a discussion of how western narratives of sexuality often require a certain repression of the elements that trouble the stability of the heteronormative “I”, both within one’s self and with in society.
In the early 1990s Laura Mulvey’s thesis concerning the patriarchal structure of an active male gaze has influenced feminist film critiques and Hollywood. Mulvey’s project is to use psychoanalysis to uncover the power of patriarchy in Hollywood cinema. Patriarchal influence upon cinema is found primarily in pleasure (pleasure in looking) or as Freud’s has put it, scopophilia. Mulvey suggests that it may be possible to create a new for of cinema due to the fact that patriarchy power to control cinematic pleasure has revealed.