preview

Willa Cather 's My Antonia And O

Better Essays

Both Willa Cather’s My Ántonia and O. E. Rölvaag’s Giants in the Earth portray the difficulties of everyday life in unexplored territory, with similar themes and context. Although the overarching themes of both novels are similar, the manner in which characters behave with each other, the dependency families have on each other, and the ability of individuals to mitigate conflict is different. Both My Ántonia and Giants in the Earth portray an array of sources causing conflict in relationships. However, they differ in the motivations of characters and intent of individual action. Both novels give unique perspectives of immigration, demonstrating how integral relationships are to survival, but also portraying how individual interests can …show more content…

Instead of attempting to resolve the conflict, viewing the Shimerdas’ as foreign and distant provides a perspective that justifies violence. This is demonstrated as “[Jake] landed Ambrosch a blow on the head” (83). Jake is able to justify the violence to himself, because the wrongdoing of Ambrosch is amplified by nativism.
Giants in the Earth conveys a greater sense of difference--a racialized depiction between “us” and “them” with a frenzied panic from Per Hansa’s family accompanying the appearance of Indians. Fear of Indian’s was common among settlers, who told stories of great massacres and atrocities committed by tribes. When Indians approach, Per Hansa and neighboring settlers are indignant, stating that “there isn’t any doubt” the land they inhabit is theirs fearing the Indians may steal it or attack his family (Rölvaag 73). Perception of Indians uncivilized and barbaric contribute to their fear, as they “watched with anxious attention the Indian band as it crept up the slope of the hill towards the crest” (68). Per Hansa creates greater distinction as he “drew such ghastly pictures to Sam of the cruelty with which the Indians would probably treat the cows”, bowing to racialized assumptions that Indians are savage (69). When he remarks that “I guess we’ll have to be satisfied with a scalp or two”, he recognizes that scalping is “the most dreadful thing in the world” (71). His recognition of the atrocity only worsens his actions, as he deems scalping

Get Access