With direct reference to at least one film, how did Hollywood address the paranoid, hysterical political climate of the 50s?
The Cold War began in 1947 between the USSR and the USA. After World War II, both countries began to distrust each other, as they knew the amount of power each country had in terms of nuclear weapons. Not only did they distrust each other, but they lacked a mutual understanding of each other’s culture. The USA believed in capitalism and the USSR believed in communism. This lack of mutual understanding caused mass paranoia within America as they feared that communists would infiltrate their society. This hysteria was known as the Red Scare which lead to “a range of actions that had a profound and enduring effect on
…show more content…
HUAC however disagreed and all ten were “found guilty of contempt of congress and each were sentence to between six and twelve months in prison”(Simkin, 1997) In 1950, Edward Dmytryk came forward and “testified at a HUAC hearing and provided the names of more than 20 industry colleagues he claimed were communists” (Hollywood Ten, 2013). This led to the beginning of a movie industry blacklist, “studio executive did not want their business to be associated with radical politics in the minds of the movie-going public and therefore agreed they would not employ anyone suspected of being affiliated with the Communist Party” (Hollywood Ten, 2013). After the hearings in 1951, others such as Elia Kazan began to cooperate with HUAC by providing names. A list of 324 names became available to HUAC, “Names of those cited as communists by cooperative witnesses were listed alphabetically. Everyone cited was blacklisted in the studios”. (Cogley, 1985, p. 492)
Public confessions were considered “personally welcomed” as it served a “means of atonement for past actions” (Genter, 2012, p. 130). Witnesses who chose to not respond were “those with something to hide” (Genter, 2012, p. 130) these confessions instigated a massive debate over “the legality of such confessions, coerced or not.” (Genter, 2012, p. 130),as employees were forced to confess due to the threat of losing their job. The defenders of the investigations argued that the confessions “helped to cleanse
The list accused 151 writers, directors and performers and claimed they were member of the Communist organization during World War II. The blacklist against Communists would make it significantly more difficult for a person to find employment in most industries and most likely would get a person fired just for even being interrogated or being any form of a suspect of Communism. Even a person who worked with a person accused of Communism had significantly less chance to be able to find a job. Ten stars that were most famous for standing up for themselves and pleaded the 5th amendment when asked to name Communists were known as the Hollywood ten. Their names were Herbert Biberman, Albert Maltz, Lester Cole, Adrian Scott, Samuel Ornitz, Dalton Trumbo, Edward Dmytryit, Ring Lardner Jr., John Howard Lawson and Alvah Bessie. The ten did not defend themselves because they were prideful Americans who saw their rights and the rights of others being harmed and decided to do something about, no. They were already asked if they were Communists when they went on a trip to California and they did not want to get charged with perjury. Some Americans did take action and saw that their rights were being put into question and decided to protect themselves, for example Alger Hiss who was accused and in order to solidify the fact that he was a Communist lawyers used his day to day schedule in full detail to solidify that his behaviors were that
In addition to fighting communism overseas, the United States battled communism within its own government. Pressured by the republicans, President Truman created a loyalty Review Board in which government employees where investigated for their loyalty. Of the 3 million who where testified, only 212 where dismissed as security risks. This method was often ineffective because individuals who had been accused of disloyalty where not allowed to see the evidence against them. Another program aimed at eliminating communist influence was HUAC, or the House Un-American Activity Committee. In 1947, HUAC questioned 43 Hollywood actors about their loyalty to the government.
People that worked in the army or were part of the movie industry had to answer to this question (McCarthyism).
In 1950 the emergence of the Second Red Scare’s driving force, Senator Joseph McCarthy, appeared and gave a speech proclaiming that America will soon be lost to communism if the people do not stand up to combat it. He revealed that night a list of 205 people working for Soviet Russia in the United States’ State Department whose intentions were to mold America from the inside to become a socialist nation. (Fitzgerald, p. 14) It was thanks to this newfound hysteria that began to break out thanks to McCarthy’s claims that the HUAC and other like-minded organizations began to gain momentum during this time period.
After the end of World War II on September 2, 1945, a new era called the Cold War began. The Cold War was a non-violent state of political and military tension between the democratic and capitalist United States and the communist Soviet Union: two of the biggest powers of the world at the time. However, they were drastically different in both economy and politics, allowing rivalry to build up. They both wanted to become the most powerful nation of the world, and both feared that the other nation would rise up to become the most powerful nation of the world.
The Hollywood Ten happened in the late 1940’s and early 1950’s. The Hollywood Ten is where there was a communist influence in the American motion picture business. Screenwriters and Directors in Hollywood Known as the Hollywood Ten received jail time and were blacklisted, meaning they could not work for major Hollywood studios. The ten people include Alvah Bessie, Herbert Biberman, Lester Cole, Edward Dmytryk, Ring Lardner Jr, John Howard Lawson, Albert Maltz, Samuel Orntiz, Robert Adrian Scott, and Dalton Trumbo. These ten people denounced the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) anti-communist hearings as a violation of their civil rights.
Although prosperity filled the 50s, controversy and dissatisfaction surrounded it also. As the picture "Senator McCarthy Extinguishes the Torch of Liberty" conveys, McCarthyism hushed the freedom of speech. (Kennedy, Cohen, and Bailey A127)The man who gave McCarthyism a name, Joseph McCarthy, ruined many lives by accusing tons of Americas of being Communists for about 5 years. The post-cold war paranoia about spies and infiltrates in the American government escalated the allegations to a whole other level, despite the lack of evidence. Many people lost their jobs, went to jail, or became shunned by the public. Senator McCarthy conducted countless numbers of speeches, investigations, and hearings. His actions proved to be so terrifying that very few spoke out against him. Only when taking the claims to the military did the people finally take a stand. Weeks afterward, the Senate condemned McCarthy for “practicing conduct unfit for a member.”
From the years of 1941 to 1949, there was an increase in suspicion and tension between the United States and the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union was a Communist country ruled by a dictator while America was a capitalist democracy that valued freedom. Their completely different beliefs and aims caused friction to form between them, which contributed to the creation of the Cold War.
While HUAC’s actions were not laudable, it paradoxically had the best interests of the American public in mind, including protecting American civil rights. Insofar as Communism seemed to threaten the American way of life, HUAC’s attempts to root out Communists reflected a concern for American civil rights. The authoritarian nature of the Communist Party, as described by some, seems to support the idea of a Communist threat to American ideals. As a friendly witness before HUAC, for example, former Communist Party member Elia Kazan confessed that he left the party because “I had enough regimentation, enough of being told what to think and say and do, enough of their habitual violation of the daily practices of democracy to which I was accustomed” (406). In his testimony, Kazan portrays the Communist party as a suppressor of civil rights (“daily practices,” such as the right to “think”
So the impact of the HUAC was playing a substance role in established the Hollywood and in blacklisting. So the blacklisting with HUAC was a small job they had which was to review the outside people. Which in return the investigation to many artist and entertainers including the Hollywood ten. Then comes McCarthy who was “the senate permanent subcommittee on investigations of the senator committee on the government operation and became its chairman in 1953”. So people would get the 5th amendment to use because the heat got rough, but most people thought that they were trying to hide something if they did that. Now Wood would ask the stupidest question to hide up the 5th amendment’s like “Do you think it would have had as good an effect upon the morale of the American people a=to preach a doctrine to them that Russia was on the very of collapse”? Which added up to people not getting heard when people were thinking the most unthinkable to people that any people would take up arm in the name of Eastland to go against anybody. Then people were saying that they didn’t understand how to live in a totalitarian dictatorship. Where Martin had died and the HUAC would have been attacking the left wing artiste group to harm them. Which implies that because of all of this embarrassment they had to
The Cold War was the name given to the time period from 1945 to 1991. After World War II, tensions began between the United States and the Soviet Union. Fighting between the United States and Soviet Union did not happen directly against each other. Instead they fought with arms races, space races, and spying. Both superpowers set aside their differences to defeat Adolf Hitler, even before the war the United States distrusted the Soviet Union. The United States disliked the way the Soviet Union ran government. They believed that the Soviet Union wanted to overthrow the non-communist governments.
In July 29,1946 William R. Wilkerson, writes “A Vote for Joe Stalin” a column in ‘The Hollywood Reporter’ naming the eleven alleged Communists that were working for Hollywood. Dalton Trumbo and seven others were on Wilkerson’s informal list, which the House Un-American Activities Committee used in their investigation.
During the late 1940’s and throughout the 1950’s, there was a great fear of Communism in America and abroad. The House Committee on Un-American Activities (HUAC) was created in 1938 as a means to investigate and weed out Communists and Communist supporters from American society. Its first major attack was on the Hollywood film industry. Blacklisting of Hollywood writers, actors, producers, directors and others suspected of Communist affiliations began with the committee's hearings in October of 1947, and flourished throughout the 1950s. Senator Joseph
Continuing his claims of suspected communists, various innocent people were questioned, and some cases ended up proving nothing because of how the information received showed little evidence of the suspects being a communist. Despite some of the cases having repeated or weak information, the Senate still called for a full investigation, making suspects tell names of others who are communists. It is stated in the article, “Those who repented and named names of suspected communists were allowed to return to business as usual. Those who refused to address the committee were cited for contempt” (McCarthyism 3). People who were suspected conformed so that they would not be held for contempt. People accused others in order to avoid the punishment for contempt, fearing how the punishment would affect their life. McCarthy’s accusations also had an effect on those who were on the lower rank as well, it reads, “Uncooperative artists were blacklisted from jobs in the entertainment industry. Years passed until many had their reputations restored” (McCarthyism 3). People conformed in fear of consequences that would practically destroy their life. Being blacklisted meant being unable to find jobs and having a ruined reputation, so civilians conformed to the law to keep their jobs and not have their lives destroyed. Conformity is achieved by fear of consequences throughout McCarthyism,
HUAC asserted that “Communists had established a significant base in the dominant medium of mass culture,” movies. HUAC further claimed that Communists were “placing subversive messages into Hollywood films.” In Mining Salt of the Earth, James J. Lorence reveals that HUAC held hearings on the “alleged influence of Communists in the motion picture industry.” After these hearings, the Motion Picture Producers’ Association issued their Waldorf Statement, declaring Hollywood’s intention to deny employment to “anyone who advocated the overthrow of the government by force” obviously referring to Communists but ultimately including “left-liberals of all