When most people think of Buddhism, they probably imagine a statue of Buddha or bald monks in orange robes praying inside a monastery. But how many people picture Buddhist nuns or women meditating under trees? Since the addition of women in religious practices, many Buddhists have found it difficult to agree on whether women truly have a place in Buddhism or not, especially regarding the profoundly spiritual aspects. The primary reason for this divide is the fact that there is no consensus of the matter across all of the sacred texts of Buddhism. In 6th-century B.C. India, a female was commonly viewed as a useless individual who was merely a burden on her family. Buddhist Studies says that as a girl, she was her parents’ burden. As a woman, …show more content…
The first ordained bhikkhuni -or Buddhist nun- was Buddha’s aunt, who was also his childhood caretaker since his mother died shortly after giving birth to him. While it is known that Buddha’s allowance for practicing female followers was not an immediate decision he made, there is speculation that his creating the eight garudhammas, or the eight weighty restrictions, “served to make clear the [nuns’] separate and inferior status compared to the men” (Janice D. Willis, p. 62, 1954). Of the eight garudhammas, one in particular states that “every nun must bow to every monk” (Thanissaro Bhikkhu, 2007), which further supports the idea of Buddha’s attempt to preserve the men’s positions above the women. What’s more, a few of the rules state that while monks are able to admonish nuns and accuse nuns of transgressions, whereas nuns are forbidden from doing the same to monks. Ironically, though, in several Buddhist scriptures, it is stated that gender differentiation can be a cause of spiritual bondage (Thanissaro Bhikkhu, …show more content…
However, according to the Pali Canon, Buddha said that it is impossible for a woman to become “‘the perfectly rightfully Enlightened One', ‘the Universal Monarch", ‘the King of Gods’, ‘the King of Death’ or ‘Brahmaa’” (Thanissaro Bhikkhu, 2007). Despite the fact that Buddha himself made this declaration, there were certain individuals who strongly disagreed with him. Based on scriptures found in Vajrayana texts, it is stated that women can achieve complete enlightenment and become the Buddha (Thanissaro Bhikkhu, 2007). Learning this information, one may wonder if Buddha’s opposing claim was just another way he tried to prevent females from ‘overpowering’ the males in the community. As time progressed, Buddha’s initial statement seemed to lose more and more credence as female Buddhists were able to rise to high positions such as lamas and even Buddhas. Well-known female Buddhas include Yeshe Tsogyal, Vajrayogini, Tara, and Simhamukha (Thanissaro Bhikkhu, 2007). There are many female followers of Buddha who achieved great respect and status for various reasons within the Buddhist community. For example, a follower by the name of Khemā was directly “praised by the Buddha for the depth of [her] understanding” (Alan Sponberg, p. 6, 1962). Other women were commended for their ability to teach the Dharma and bring followers to enlightenment without any male
says a monk should treat all women as female relatives, that is, he should view
In many cultures, the roles of women vary reluctantly. While researching the many aspects of Buddhism, the religion is sometimes practiced differently and the roles of women differs. According to Experiencing World Religions, (Molloy, 127) Buddhism is one of the world's oldest yet most significant religions thus far. It has influenced many cultures, originating from India and making its way to migrate throughout the country of Asia, and women have been involved since the very first day. In today’s society, although men are predominantly inferior over women, women are granted the same opportunities. Just like many other societies in other countries or many other religions there are discriminations and prejucial acts against women. Although, woman are offered the second class citizenship in many Buddhist traditions, a woman's role is very important when helping maintain the religion resulting in mass population of worshipers , fulfilling the duties as caregivers and also wives to their husbands, and also providing any assistance if needed in the community. (Molloy, 127)
The Sangha, the Buddhist monastic order, comprises Bhikku (monks), Bhikkuni (nuns), laymen, and laywomen. While the Bhikku and Bhikkuni depend upon the laywomen and men for economic support, the lay community depends on them for spiritual guidance and ritualistic practices. This well-rounded mutual relationship is clearly a division not only amongst religious status, but determined by gender as well. This is quite a contradiction with the Buddhist belief that your physical self is impermanent and ultimately attachment to your illusory self will cause you suffering. The second Noble Truth states that suffering originates from our ongoing desire, a clinging to possessions, attachments, and self. Why would a religion founded in the idea of shedding attachment focus so much on gender, which is an attachment? I feel that the Buddha’s hesitation in allowing women to be initially recognized in the Sangha originates from his early childhood convictions of women, fear of the Dharma becoming further compromised, and ultimately leading to the deterioration of Buddhism altogether. The Buddha’s hesitations regarding women becoming monastics seem to be questionable because of the way women have responded to this discrimination even during the Buddha’s lifetime. These women are evidently devoted to the ideals and teachings of Buddhism because of their ability to shed attachments and embody a fully monastic lifestyle. As they are shedding their attachments they give up their gender.
Wu Zhao, the first female emperor of China, rose to power during the Tang Dynasty and her active role with Buddhism fabricated a perpetual impact in the Chinese society as a whole. There is no doubt that Buddhism and the Tang administration, under Wu’s reign, formed a symbiotic relationship with one another. She is considered to be one of the most prominent advocators of the religion during the era. Her efforts to spread of Buddhism and the monetary support help Buddhism to expand throughout the people significantly, which provide the religion another source of financial income to spread even further. Regardless of Empress Wu’s intention, she has furnished the religion in numerous ways, but what did she receive in return? This proposes
According to the “Rites” [a classical text], it was a rule to begin to teach children to read at the age of eight years and by the age of fifteen years they ought then to be ready for culture training. (Strayer 2011, 245) Ban Zhao stated “Yet only to teach men and not to teach women- …” (Strayer 2011), because she felt education for women was important to maintain in a proper relationship between the men and women. In the Chinese culture, husband and wife were taught to mutually respect each other. Chinese women were controlled by their husbands. If a husband does not control his wife, then the rules of conduct manifesting his wife authority are abandoned and broken. (Strayer 2011, 245). In Chinese gender system, women were to have four qualifications, which were called Womanly Qualifications: (1) womanly virtue; (2) womanly words; (3) womanly bearing; (4) womanly work. (Strayer 2011, 246) .They were also taught to be humble. Women in the Indian culture were known for the homemakers in their society. Women were aware of the repression of women, but they were allowed to escape because of religion. Indian women became Buddhist so they could escape from households. Indian were forced to participate in rituals. Nibbana’s
Just as the British ignored women’s perspective, so did the Indian men from both secular and religious backgrounds. Geraldine Forbes (1996) argues that the female approach is often missing in history and thus, she attempts to privilege women’s own accounts, whether it be through their oral histories, folktales, memoirs, journals, documents, etc. I believe the same could have been done in regards to the sati, primary documents such as the Ramayana reveal that there was female opposition to the sati (in the case of Sita). The introduction of the “woman question” was a significant step in South Asian history in terms of initiating the movement for women’s rights, however, it lacked the necessary voice from Indian women
As a result of these reviews, the ongoing reconstruction of the social status and roles of Hindu women has brought about many new changes in Hinduism. Some of these changes include changes in education, health measures, problems of early marriages, the positions of widows, and the representation of women in governing bodies (Desai, et al., 1995). For example, within Hinduism now,
Whether it is in a polytheistic or a monotheistic religion, the gender of divinity is always a topic given great attention. Although Buddhism doesn’t put much focus on gods in the teaching, it does include certain religious aspects such as praying to the higher beings. The feminine divine traits in Buddhism can be found with a closer examination on the feminine metaphors in the Buddhist scriptures. While Buddhas are predominantly in male form, divine beings like Bodhisattvas often appears to be female figures including Kwan Yin and Tara. The concept of Buddha nature is described as “tathagata garbha” at times, which means Buddha womb. The imagery of this spiritual womb nurturing the nature for all beings implies the significance of this feminine feature. Another example is how the Buddha’s wisdom is referred to as a ‘she’ in some Buddhist texts. The involvement of both feminine and masculine traits seems to underline the irrelevance of gender in Buddhahood. On the other hand, in Christianity a prevailing image of God being the ‘Father’ is developed. The teachings of Jesus powerfully delineate God as a kind and merciful father accepting and guiding his children with no discrimination. In fact, there is only one explicit example in the scriptures comparing God seeking a sinner to a housewife in search of a lost coin. In addition to the masculine image of God, it is argued that between two human sexes, Jesus as a male is
In the beginning of the war, around 1941, most American women lived as their mothers previously had. Women were supposed to have jobs just until they were married and those who did work after they were married or were mothers were regarded with a sense of pity and scorn from society. In a pre-war poll, 82 percent of Americans believed a wife should not work if her husband did. A majority of Americans believed there should have been a law to prohibit it since rural and city women, alike spent about 50 hours a week on household chores alone.
Traditionally, an Indian woman had only four roles and those were; Her role as a daughter, wife, sister, and lastly, a mother. The women in today’s time however are experiencing far reaching changes and are entering into new fields that were unknown to them. They are actively participating in social, economic and political activities. Unlike the older times, women today have received higher education.
Buddhism’s teachings are paradoxical in many ways, and even the very definition of Nirvana is not clear. Nirvana is not a place like heaven for Christianity, but rather an eternal state of being. It is the state in which the law of Karma and the rebirth cycle come to an end. Achieving enlightenment also implies to be able to see things as they are. Since Buddhism emphasizes the importance of the soul more than the body, I wonder if there is gender discrimination within Buddhism, and to a larger extent I find it interesting to question how the notion of gender impacts the application of the Buddhist philosophy? Therefore, I will, throughout this
An often controversial issue within politics is how woman are viewed and treated in the Hindu religion. The role of woman in Hinduism is often disputed and positions range from quite reasonable to highly antagonistic. An often overlooked aspect is that, Hinduism is more of a way of life then a Religion. This is because Hinduism requires that we see the same reality in all the diversity of creation; that we see the same Self in all beings. Hindu women within this religion would view themselves as an important part of the family, but this is not shown through the contents of the Manusmriti. The Manusmriti directly translated is “Laws of Manu,” or “Institutions of Manu,” is regarded as the foundational
“In Tantric Buddhism, we are dealing with a misogynist, destructive, masculine philosophy and religion which is hostile to life – i.e. the precise opposite of that for which it is trustingly and magnanimously welcomed in the figure of the Dalai Lama.”[1] Within Tibetan Buddhism, there is an inherent contradiction regarding the status of women. Although in many aspects women are seen and treated as inferior to men, several of the ancient and fundamental values of Tibetan Buddhism, and more specifically Tantric Buddhism, emphasize equality of the sexes, universal compassion, and most importantly the significant and essential role of the woman. Tibetan Buddhist nuns have been trying to
leaders of Buddhism to be only male monks (Khuankaew). It does not matter if the nun has been
Hinduism is so entwined in Indian culture, as I have shown, that most other cultures have a difficult time assimilating Hinduism into their own society. Even when Hinduism is assimilated into a culture, such as Hindu movements in the United States, women are sure to find discrimination in not only the traditional gurus and swamis who are teaching them, but sexist commentaries deeply ingrained in religious texts. Buddhism suffers from the opposite extreme. The Buddha originally banned women from monastic practice but later reversed his decision, allowing them to practice in separate quarters. Buddhist scriptures say very little about women, treating them as equals.