preview

1. Introduction . Vania Leveille And Susan Mizner’S “Aclu:

Decent Essays

1. Introduction Vania Leveille and Susan Mizner’s “ACLU: Gun control laws should be fair” argues against a law repealed by Congress in February that would have required the registration of Social Security recipients with mental disabilities to prevent gun ownership. They state that because the mentally disabled are more likely to be victims than perpetrators of violence, fear about them owning guns is prejudiced and as a result, obstructs their civil rights. In my rebuttal, I counter their statistic about mentally disabled victims, arguing its irrelevance in mass shooter situations and the subsequent unsoundness of their argument. Finally, I explain how unhealthy mental conditions can lead to unsafe consequences in day-to-day situations …show more content…

However, registering innocent, mentally disabled people based on less evidence would serve as a biased obstruction of the civil rights of Americans. Millions of blameless people would become part of a “criminal” database and be robbed unnecessarily of a civil right, comparable to the right to vote or have a child. Thus, such a law should never be passed. Leveille and Mizner’s argument takes on the following form: P1) Laws that involve the loss of a civil right, such as that to own guns, should be based on real data from the American population. P2) Laws that involve the loss of a civil right and do not have any statistical correlation or reasoning are based on prejudice and should not be passed. P3) The recently repealed executive order would have required the registration of many mentally disabled Americans into a background check system to prevent them from owning guns. P4) According to statistics, mentally disabled people are more likely to be victims than perpetrators of violence. C) The law requiring the registration of mentally disabled people into a background check system to prevent them from owning guns is based on prejudice rather than data and should not be passed. 3. Rebuttal My rebuttal of Leveille and Mizner’s argument centers on the ideas behind premise 4 and how they lead

Get Access