24 Joel Surnow Analysis

In contrast, some individuals may debate that torture and even some more minuscule forms of torture can be beneficial to obtaining the information needed. It is debated that torture has been used in a large portion of political systems in history, and that the “degree” of torture is a significant component when deciphering right vs. wrong. Moher argues that in a political system where torture is justifiable and legal, the torture used would be less extreme than what it is today (Moher, 2013). It is reasoned that different degrees of torture are more acceptable than others, in that some are less psychologically and physically harming. A

In “The Torture Myth”, the author, Anne Applebaum successfully uses logos by including quotes from various sources to support her main claim. Her main claim is the following: “Perhaps it's reassuring to tell ourselves tales about the new forms of "toughness" we need, or to talk about the special rules we will create to defeat this special enemy. Unfortunately, that toughness is self-deceptive and self-destructive. Ultimately it will be self-defeating as well.”(Applebaum) Throughout the piece, she provides several expert testimonies to enforce her claim. The situation of this writing is to clarify what society thinks the effectiveness of torture is compared to the reality. The target audience of this piece is educated people that read the Washington Post, but more specifically law enforcement personnel and or agencies that can possibly use this information in the field. The purpose of this article is to inform society about the misconceptions regarding torture. Although people think that torture is an effective method, because of Applebaum's successful use of logos, diction, and repetition, it is understood that torture is ultimately self-defeating and self-destructive.

Television has become a vital aspect of daily life, within modern society; every aspect of television exhibits, to a certain extent, a reliance on genre (Mittell, 2001). Industries rely on genre to produce programs, and audiences use genres as a means of organizing fan practices (Mittell, 2001). According to a 2006 Nelson Media Research study, ratings confirm that aside from prime time shows such as American Idol and Survivor, part-time crime drama’s have been classified as one of the most favoured genre (DeTardo-Bora, pg. 154, 2009). The relationship between the media and criminal justice system is delicate, where more often than not, crimes are portrayed in a false light (Graveline, pg. 1, 2015). These misconceptions lead to

Under no circumstances should torture be an acceptable method to gain intelligence. In specific situations, stress positions can be adequate as long as they’re still within the parameters of the Geneva Conventions. The United States signed the document at the Convention Against Torture and thus needs to uphold the conditions of the agreement. Through the works of Hooks and Mosher and the Torture Memos, I hope to justify my belief that torture is unacceptable.

In regard to physical torture, according to Ashley McCulley: It is common for torturers to use various techniques in order to prevent scarring and evidence of torture. The after-effects that torture causes are from the repeated intrusion and attack of one’s mind. (Bufacchi & Arrigo) The second premise is proven to be strong because first-hand evidence shows that information that is gathered as a result of torture is false information or a false confession. People will say anything to make the torturing stop if only for a little while. (As cited in Bufacchi & Arrigo) during the Vietnam War Commander James Stockdale ordered the other American Prisoners of War to ‘resist to the point of permanent injury or loss of mental faculty, and then fall back on deceit and distortion’. Also, it has been proven that captives may produce false information without knowing that it is false. The production of misinformation often happens when the captive is deemed “expendable”

Torture should be used as an intelligence gathering tool for gaining information, a fine example of when torture would be the ideal thing to do is in interrogations with dangerous terrorists that have plans to harm hundreds or thousands of U.S citizens with future attacks. Bill Harlow, a former CIA official that served as a CIA spokesmen from 1997 to 2004 was interviewed by a PBS reporter in December 10, 2014. Harlow was asked if he thought that torture was effective and gave an answer that came from his experience with the matter. Bill Harlow answered, “Well to start I would

In this essay I will talk about the torturing of prisoners in Abu Ghraib. I will also write about the Stanley Milgrim Experiment and the Stanford Prison Experiment. All of these relate to one of the topics we have covered this term.

P1: Torture is used to inflict severe pain to gain information, but is not always effective.

Tom McCarthy holds three green pens in his shirt pocket and has a laugh so contagious that makes his students laugh along with him. This man, whose dark, maniacal sense of humor pokes at the corruption of the world, is a re-employed teacher of the seventh-grade students.

The use of enhanced interrogation techniques was not effective in eliciting good information. The majority, if not all, of those interned at Abu Ghraib were men without affiliation with the group(s) that the United States government was trying to ascertain information about. In a later investigation into the use of torture as a method of interrogation by the US government, especially waterboarding, results showed that torture was a) not a moral or ethical means of obtaining information, and b) was not effective in obtaining said

This article addresses harsh interrogation and if it is justified to act out in a harmful way towards the guilty. In the beginning of this article you were debriefed on the history of tortious interrogations that people used to endure in order to get information out of them. The author of this article ultimately believes that essentially people want to harm people who has hurt them and humiliate those who has made them feel vulnerable so possibly that is where people get the satisfaction of the severe interrogation. The author also believes that people will justify the harsh treatments to others who are named guilty rather than those whom are innocent. To back up this claim the author conducts an experiment where people are put in a fake scenario to see what tactic they will choose.

“The healthy man does not torture others - generally it is the tortured who turn into torturers.” (Carl Jung). Wise words from a man of much honor and knowledge of the totalitarian regimes around the world he lives in. Throughout documented history, torture and force played a role in nearly every totalitarian government. From Adolf Hitler in Nazi Germany, to Joseph Stalin 's Soviet Union the belief of force and hurting people has been alive, active in the minds of mad men in even the most current of times. Older societies like our own believed in a way of torturing, it was just a way of getting what was needed from the specific person, no thoughts of depth going into how it might affect the person or society as a whole. Obviously torture and force were as real today as when our main source of insight, the novel, 1984, was written. This book talks about the horrors of torture our main character was forced into. This comes as a hard pill to swallow knowing that the author of the book more than likely got his inspiration from the totalitarian governments in existence during his time of life. More real than anything else in life is fear through torture, the real life thought of being tortured sends shock waves of fear into people, one of the worst of consequences these people live in is oppression and outwardly living and believing the way their governments want, this leads to a halt in a civilization 's culture and ideas sadly which in turn has a trickle effect and can affect

The practice of torture by United States officials has become one of the most controversial elements of military history. The debate of its use in gathering intelligence has been particularly prevalent since the Bush administration. Most recently, a detailed and graphic scene of torture was presented in the movie Zero Dark Thirty. Proponents for the use of torture state that it is necessary for intelligence gathering and that ethics should be waved aside. Opponents argue that it is not becoming of American practices and it is not a reliable source for intelligence gathering. The public debates on this issue have forced policy makers and military officials to look at whether or not torture, particularly waterboarding, should be legal. The

Torture is a violent method used to gather intelligence out of someone. Although torture seems like a great technique used to get information out of someone, it is immoral and is not as great as you might think. Some people hate the fact that other individuals get tortured. You could end up getting false information because nowadays people will say anything in order to stop getting hurt. There are many other ways someone could be intimidated enough to give up information without physical abuse.

Reality television has turned into a noteworthy piece of our way of life. The shows are described to be fun, engaging and acquaint society with new points of view. In the wake of a monotonous day at work, it 's decent to return home and watch something careless on television, while unwinding. While the debate that violence in the media is making for a brutal culture has been made a million times, sometime recently, I am striving to make an alternate relationship. As we are aware, the larger part of reality television contains some sort of harsh circumstance, whether verbal, emotional, physical, money related, or potentially sexual. Despite the fact that the predominance of this violence is tricky all by itself, the way that these shows are taped or situated in local circumstances is particularly concerning. Police activity being filmed for reality television is a prime example of a particularly concerning reality television. These particular television shows includes but are not limited to The First 48, COPS, Police Women of Memphis, etc. These particular shows display events that can be labeled as brutal, violent and intense. Majority of the population, are in agreeance that, that level of law enforcement tactics and incidents should not be displayed or available to the general public. According to Dowler (2002), public knowledge of crime and justice is largely derived from the media. The purpose of this paper is to discuss the dangers involved in filming