A Comparison between Billy Liar and Shirley Valentine
I have just been studying Billy Liar and performing it as part of my mock scripted drama GCSE, and have been asked to compare this theatre script to the film script of Shirley Valentine. I have already given the first difference between these two scripts; one is a theatre script and the other is designed specifically for the big screen.
Billy Liar was originally a novel written by Keith Waterhouse, who with the help of Willis Hall made it into a theatre script in the
1960's. Billy is an imaginative youth who is fighting to get out of his complacent, cliché-ridden background. He was born and brought up in a town in Yorkshire and lives with his father, Geoffrey, mother,
…show more content…
Shirley leaves without informing Joe and leaves him to fend for himself for two weeks. On the plane Jane meets a man and goes off with him leaving Shirley on her own. Slowly
Shirley rediscovers herself and meets a bar owner called Costas who she has an affair with. By the end of the two weeks Shirley does not want to leave and makes the decision to stay behind in Greece and get a job. Joe on the other hand wants her back but she refuses, and in the last scene of the play we see that Joe makes the effort and goes out to Greece to win Shirley back.
Because both scripts are designed for different purposes the dialogue in each one is very different. In Billy Liar the dialogue is quite lengthy and quite adult, proper and formal in the way it is constructed. This would be down to the time at which it was written.
In the 1960's the Lord Chancellor was very tough on censorship. Any swearing or even slightly risqué images were changed or censored completely. The strongest word used within the play is probably
'bloody' which Geoffrey says a lot and even this, is a bit 'close to the bone'. Whereas when Shirley Valentine was written there was not such a strong censorship law. In Shirley Valentine there is a lot of risqué language and many sexual innuendoes. The dialogue is a also very brief, there is no need for such long and perfectly formed
sentences
Later on after her first marriage has ended we can see that she eventually overcomes her desire to avoid confusion in her second marriage to Joe, after he has humiliated
He does not understand why his own mother would do such a thing to him. During this moment, Joe begins to transition from precociousness to the confrontation stage. After he kills his mother, he is confronted by Shola, who tells him that his mother is good and she is not the devil. Joe arrives at the Church with his mother’s body being carried in his arms. He lays her at the alter and begins to pray for forgiveness and to say his final goodbyes. His father rudely suggests that he removes Nunu’s body from the church. Joe’s will for his mother and his emotions got the best of him when he confronted his father about the truth and him being his child. Joe was intensely outraged and sat the church on fire burning himself and his father. At the moment of Joe’s death, Joe was in the internalization stage of black consciousness. Joe began to have positive attitudes about his mother’s culture and beliefs.
As opposed to communicating his outrage he tries to avoid panicking. This is either an indication of incredible resilience or utter shortcoming. There, on the other hand, is a moment when Joe demonstrates that his pride has been harmed, to be specific when he leaves the coin under his wife's cushion in the wake of laying down with her. This is a sudden turn in an identity that is apparently unequipped for harming someone else. Anyhow who can accuse the poor man for he has seen his entire world go into disrepair after the treachery of his loved one. The integrity of his character is completely shown in his pardoning toward the end of the story.
“While the 1984 original is hardly a perfect film, New Footloose has some hefty shoes to fill,” as stated by Benjamin Wood. The original movie and new make of the movie Footloose are perfect examples of change in pop culture. In my essay, I have decided to compare and contrast the values and characteristics of these two movies. From the first to the second there are the same basic ideas, but so many differences in the characters and events.
Billie was born to the name, Eleanora Fagan on April 7, 1915. She was born in Philadelphia but grew up in the Fell's Point section of Baltimore. Her mother, was just 13 at the time of her birth; her father, was 15. Holidays' teenage parents, Sadie Harris (aka Fagan) and probable father, Clarence Holiday, never married, and they did not live together for a long time. Clarence, a banjo and guitar player worked with Fletcher Henderson's band in the early 30s. He remains a shady figure who left his family. Clarence would often be away from home, and during the stay with Henderson, which lasted until 1932, the guitarist severed connections with the Fagans. Billie was an angry chile who lived a hard life. She was raped at the age of 10 soon
When Janie speaks up against him at the end of Chapter 8, Joe lashes back telling her that she wishes she would die. Janie continues to tell him the truth about his own life. She tells him how she has done everything to satisfy him, and how she
“Becoming Jane” is based on the book called “Becoming Jane Austen” by Jon Hunter Spence. Jane Austen was the women writer who wrote realistic and charming stories by using delicately sensitive and humorous style when the grotesque and romantic fictions were prevailing. Later on, Austen was called as women Shakespeare. Becoming Jane is the movie version of how Jane Austen’s famous book “Pride and Prejudice” was affected by her first love, Tom LeFroy. A lot of people thought Jane Austen as the women who is polite and meticulous but married to the novel and writing all the time.
In the beginning Shirley is talking about her husband who is a Doctor and he is looking for better health and business. He goes to a mining camp because a friend
It’s almost like he knew he couldn’t do anything about what his future had in store for him but to either quit doing what he loved for the sake of his life or keep pushing his body mentally and physically simply for the love of the sport of climbing. Eventually the “right” summit will catch up to him and sadly take his life because he didn’t know when to stop or when to say no to a tough opponent. Climbers and other athletes of extreme sports don’t like to have a limit and go beyond measures putting their lives in potential life threatening situations. Joe realizes that he is one of those people now, being controlled by the love of the sport and not knowing what the sport was actually going to do to his body and that it could eventually take his
Billy: Libby I have never met anyone like you and even though we don’t know each other that well I want to develop on our friend ship. What do you think?
Gordon’s mistress asked Jean to meet up with her. She mistook Jean as Gordon’s secrete lover. Jean lied to her by saying that Gordon had left a love message before he died. The mistress was very shocked to hear that Gordon said he loved her. Before Jean continue the conversation, Gordon’s mother called. Jean then left the woman to Mrs.Gottlieb’s(Gordon’s mother) house. Jean lied to Gordon’s family by pretending to be a former co-worker. Jean and Mrs.Gottlieb shared conversation about Gordon. Then, Jean learned that Gordon has been
He does not give up in the play, he produces ways to accomplish what he wants and when he wants it. He did in fact take proper times to pause and continue with what he had to fell internally, and sometimes shared it with the audience. Lastly, the actor did in fact act properly with the props and environment, je was comfortable and knew what needed to be done, when to do it, how to do it, and where to be.
People say there are moments that will stick with you no matter how much time has passed. I am positive this statement is true for the Billy Joel Concert that I attended at Wrigley Field in Chicago on August 11th. The tickets were a gift given to me by my parents for my Birthday back in January. They were hidden in a box with a stack of about 50 manilla envelopes which my parents found very funny. I couldn’t believe my eyes when I finally found the tickets, I had never been to a concert before, unless you count seeing the Perry Choir and Band, so there was much anticipation.
mentally as time goes on. She is terrified of losing Joe.There is deeper meaning in the lives of
It was Valentine’s Day at my school. It was so much fun even though I just broke up with my boyfriend. We were still friends I guess, but he kept acting weird. He always said it was my friends fault for our brake up but it wasn’t. Today I just wanted to have fun with my friends. We had no homework and I got to have a bunch of enjoyable moments with my friends, but I don’t know. Something felt off. It felt like there was someone watching us. Someone following our every move. I just left that idea alone. My friends and I went to all the Valentine Stations at school. The first station was a crafting station, where we made red and pink hearts out of rough paper. We then had to put a name of our valentine or a special one. But of course, we did