preview

Aldo Leopold Summary

Decent Essays

Aldo Leopold takes the stance of both a sportsman, and a conservationist. He wants to see the joining and collaboration of sportspersons and conservationist to help preserve and/or regain wildlife. Although he speaks as a sportsman as well as conservationist, he makes it clear that he does not condone all the past actions of sportspersons (p. 453). He points out that both the sportsmen and wildlife protectionists have made “blunders” in the past regarding the welfare of wildlife, but he states that “the worthiness of any cause is not measured by its clean record, but by its readiness to see the blots when they are pointed out, and to change its mind (p. 453). He feels that the two groups are too divided, focusing on the other’s past failures, …show more content…

She begins her writing with the very bold statement: “Hunting is an act of violence (p. 454).” She makes it very clear from square one that she does not support hunting. She then goes on to attack the claim that hunting is a sport, saying that hunting cannot be a sport because the animal has not consented to the “game” (p.455). She then goes on to describe the three types of hunters: the happy hunter, who hunts for psychological need, the holist hunter, who hunts for ecological need, and the holy hunter, who hunts for spiritual needs (p.456-8). Kheel disputes each hunter’s reasoning. She says that the happy hunter’s need and desire to hunt is immoral because it pays no consideration to the animal (p.456-7). As for the holist hunter, Kheel says that he or she overlooks “the vast differences between human predation and natural predation (p. 457-8). In nature, predators prey on the weak, sick, old, and young, but human hunters prey on the fittest individuals in the ecosystem, taking out the strongest members of a species and leaving that species vulnerable (p. 458). Finally, Kheel attacks the holy hunter on the grounds that it is unethical to claim the religious beliefs from another culture to justify your actions (p.

Get Access