preview

Analysis Of Bourgois And Schonberg 's ' Gray Zone '

Better Essays

Bourgois and Schonberg (2009, p. 15) first explore the concept of the ‘gray zone’ in the introduction, the purpose of using this theory to gain a better understanding of how the state structural forces created a morally ambiguous zone in which the Edgewater homeless exist, where survival imperatives overcome human decency. As the Edgewater homeless fight and struggle to survive another day, they use manipulations and deceit to gain advantage over their fellow campmates, in order to decrease their own personal suffering under conditions of extreme poverty and police repression. Primo Levi is stated as the source of this theory, comparing the ethical wasteland of the concentration camps with the Edgewater Boulevard and the neoliberalism with …show more content…

20; Levi, Rosenthal & Bailey 2013, 241). In the case of the Edgewater homeless, this photo ethnography urges the reader to move beyond base simplistic assumptions and stigma surrounding the community and move towards a greater understand of how large coercive constraints interact with intimate behaviour, and how this contributes to, and continue to contribute to, the Edgewater homeless circumstances and suffering (Bourgois & Schonberg 2009, p.20). Bourgois and Schonberg (2009, pp. 20, 318) state that the Edgewater Boulevard is home to the social pariahs who have hit rock bottom, fleeing and expelled from family, the labour force and government services, and all the while blaming themselves for their fate. It is the gray zone that justifies this self-condemnation and where interpersonal violence and betrayal can fester, playing out between loved ones or themselves (Bourgois & Schonberg 2009, p. 318). Bourgois and Schonberg (2009, p. 318) state that it is this everyday spectacle of gray zone behaviour that obscures impact of long-term social forces and legitimizes purposefully hostile or dysfunctional government policies towards the poor.
Bourgois and Schonberg (2009, p. 20) explain that their use of the ‘gray zone’ when applied to the Edgewater homeless can be seen as ‘operating along a continuum of insupportable, structurally

Get Access