Rationale.
This rationale will explore the case of Oscar Pistorius and how he shot and killed his girlfriend Reeva steenkamp in his Pretoria home. I will discuss why I chose to look at this particular case and why it generated so much media interest. I will explain why I used narrative analysis as the media analysis technique and why it was relevant to this particular case. This rationale will consider how the case portrays crime, Pistorius as the criminal, Reeva Steenkamp as the victim and the criminal justice system in South Africa.
I chose to look at this item because the news that Pistorius had killed his girlfriend shocked the world. He was a popular Paralympic champion that had achieved great success at the London Olympics who had significantly changed public attitudes towards Paralympic athletics.
Bordwell and Thompson (cited in Gillespie and Toynbee, 2006:81) define a ‘narrative’ as a chain of events in cause-effect relationship occurring in time and space. A narrative also begins and ends and is similar to storytelling. Narrative analysis was the most appropriate method of analysis because the case involved a chain of events that happened before Steenkamp was shot for example, the first time the couple made their relationship public as well as the text messages they exchanged before her death. Narrative analysis (Gillespie and Toynbee, 2006:82) enables us to tell the story from a particular perspective for example, I considered Pistorius’ version of what happened
In the case of Adam Lanza’s crime I do believe there is a theory that may help explain his action. One of the theories that caught my eye in the book was social process theory. This theory states, “The view that criminality is a function of people’s interactions with various organizations, institutions, and processes in society”(Siegel). In my opinion the social institutions Adams was in played a key role in his actions. His family and school definitely had a big impact on why he decided to go kill innocent individuals. First of all Adam was not mentally stable from a young age, which should have been addressed by the parents. Adam was diagnosed with Sensory processing and Asperger autism that lead him to be very quite and shy. He was also
The National Geographic film, A Portrait of a Killer, examines the types of stress that living beings can endure, and how it can thus affect the rest of their bodies. Severe chronic stress can lead even lead to the destruction of brain cells. Dr. Robert Sapolsky is a neurobiologist of Stanford University who has been researching stress for over thirty years. In order to study stress and its implications upon nonhumans, he went to Africa to study baboons. This species has only three hours of stress caused by eating, and the rest of their daily routine is consumed by about nine hours of free time. Much like Western society, baboons socially stress out one another, as they have social hierarchies to regulate how them interact with one another.
In “ ‘A Steep Price…’” it analyzed the opinions of the public, media, victim, and aggressor in defending their particular take on the case. The article offers mild bias, so it does not completely report the events of the case, because it mostly focuses on the opinionated effects and not so much the facts. In “Feminist Put Judge...”, major bias is introduced by claiming to be in support of the feminist cause; however, the article uses a stronger ethical appeal to attract a broader, more unified audience. In “Here’s the Powerful Letter…”, the author recants the letter the victim wrote to her attacker, Brock Turner. She not only aims for the audience to feel the distress and havoc the case has relinquished on her life, but also a chance to spread a more positive message to thank her supporters while encouraging her audience to stand up for themselves and their self worth. The overall purpose of analyzing all these different media sources is to be able to recognize how the multiple points of view that a story can be told from will alter the objectivity of the event. A society’s culture will emphasis bias or certain point of views to get the public to believe one interpretation of the story based on the
In this article, “Who Killed the Jeff Davis 8”, Ethan Brown, the author, attempted to solve the murder case and prove the police authorities to being wrong and being responsible for the murders of the town. The main problem of this article is determining who is responsible for the murders of those eight women everyone’s contradicting stories. In an attempt to figure out what really happened Brown includes factual evidence from interviews and shocking statistics to inform the reader of what’s going on in the article. By providing such information, Brown indulges the audience into the full experience of solving the murder case.
The media played a large role in narrating the story of how and why the boy’s death occurred. Giroux uses the term “privatized discourse” in discussing the treatment of the case within American media and culture. “...Dangerous because they invoke wider social considerations and prevent [them] from wallowing in a purely privatized discourse that, in the end, for instance, only allows [them] to focus on the most narrow and restricted of issues such as the personality of the shooter, George Zimmerman” (Giroux 2**). The preceding quote highlights one of Giroux’s main focuses, the tendency for the public
This case is of interest to both myself and society because Truscott was wrongly convicted based on the limited scientific knowledge available in 1959, and the police’s tunnel vision. They were so adamant on finding the killer that they became fixated on Truscott as the only suspect, and did’t bother widening their search. Because of this, evidence was tampered to frame Truscott. What happened to Truscott was a miscarriage of justice, which affects society’s confidence in the legal system, and it undermines the criminal justice system’s legitimacy.
This particular task I am going to be identifying and critically be assessing some of the psychological and sociological perspectives in relation to Wests Murder case but in particular focusing on Rose West’s trial on why she was given the guilty verdict. I will go onto explaining the basic and background of the case, the reasons on why the decision was reached and how both the prosecution and defence put across their argument to the courts.
Flanagan shot himself during the car chase with police officers that ensued following the attack and died of his injuries. As previously mentioned, there has since been discussion surrounding the appropriateness of the coverage that followed these attacks. It is relevant to analyse and examine the media coverage of the tragedy in order to gain a thorough understanding of how this incident is indeed an ethical dilemma.
In chapters five “Chasing My Stolen Bicycle” and seven “Duke Lacrosse Players Relieved Case has ‘Closure’”, they share a similar theme. They both involve risk, harm, and seriousness. They both involve the role of a prosecutor, as well as deal with some type of crime.
As seen in his article, Collier describes Trayvon Martin as an “unarmed black teenager” and George Zimmerman as the “nervous neighborhood vilgilante” (Collier 81). By describing them as such, he is effective in making the reader sympathize with the victim; Trayvon Martin in this example. Collier further uses pathos in his article by telling a true story of the effects for using a gun for self defense.
How can the police act out in such an outrageous behavior as they have done so? How can they charge an individual based on their intuition? Or better yet, how can a police officer brutally beat an individual within an interrogation? Through the criminology theory; critical and conflict I will use these method to potentially explain the crimes that were enacted within the Amanda Knox vs. Perugia, Italy.
The purpose of this paper is to discuss and analyze the practices conducted by law enforcement during the investigation of the murder of Ashley Smith. The following pages will discuss the crime scene investigation, the evidence collection, the investigative steps following the initial crime scene investigation, the interviews of witnesses and suspects, and other strategies performed by the acting case investigators. Constitutional challenges have surfaced regarding specific pieces of critical evidence and a section of this paper will analyze the admissibility of this evidence. Lastly this case’s law enforcement processes will be contrasted with textbook processes in an effort to determine the validity of the case’s outcome.
In this poem, ‘The Man He Killed’, the poet Thomas Hardy explores a complex theme, which is war, using the simplest language. Throughout this essay I will be discussing the thoughts and opinions Hardy has on war.
My project will attempt to draw on both differences and similarities between the primary motivations of the pair. Despite the duo never meeting, nor experiencing first hand company of each other, their motives and causes of certain anomalous human behaviour were very similar. By using the symbolic interactionist approach regarding the creation of the killers’ reality and their ‘self’ I will be exhibiting academic and practical applications of the paradigm’s theoretical approach (a theoretical approach that tends to rely on dialogic methods; methods combining observation and interviewing with approaches that foster conversation and reflection) to try and explain the causes behind why such heinous crimes took place and to answer the question as to whether Dahmer, Nilsen, or both, were in fact killing for company.
Broken Lives written by Estelle Blackburn is an expository text, which through research has presented that nineteen year old John Button was wrongfully convicted of killing his seventeen year old girlfriend Rosemary Anderson in a hit and run. I believe through my reading of Broken Lives that the key factor of expository texts is to explore awkward questions deeply and critically. In this case who was guilty of killing Rosemary Anderson in a hit and run, John Button or Eric Edgar Cooke, and the effect of Cooke’s crimes and murders had on people.