preview

Analysis Of The Loons By Margaret Laurence

Good Essays

The Loons: A Girls Cry for Belonging
Although some readers might think Margaret Laurence's short story “The Loons” is about the naivety of a young girl named Vanessa who spent her days fantasizing about native american culture, it is in fact about the adversity an individual faces when presented with a lack of belonging. Laurence employs this idea through the loss and mourning of her two main characters. Through Vanessa McLeod and Piquette Tonnerres she shows how one individual’s perpetual need of belonging influences the others ulterior reality. She does this to showcase the disastrous effects of a dominant society on the prior inhabitants of the land and how it relates to a feeling loss and mourning.
Although Laurence does not say so directly, she tries to get the reader to notice that the loons and Piquette are foils of each other. I agree with what she is saying in that she utilizes Piquette to represent the cause and effect that actions have on lesser represented groups.The loons lived a simple existence at Diamond Lake up until the day where the government made Galloping Mountain into a national park. “They re-named the lake to Wapakata as they felt it would have greater appeal to tourists. As a result, this caused the once majestic and abundant loon population to disappear from the lake. Their Plaintive song to never be sung on those waters again.

Laurence adds this violation and disappearance of the loons to illuminate, for the narrator Vanessa, Piquettes refusal to accompany her to the lake in her childhood. Piquette all to well knows the loons song as she is a loon herself. She knows what it is like to be “constantly searching for some place of belonging. Eventually you’re unable to find such a place, and you cease to care if you live or not” (Laurence 278). She is the only one to hear and relate to the crying of the loons. Throughout Piquettes life she mourns for her lack of belonging.
At an early age Vanessa’s naivety of Piquettes ethnicity prohibits her from seeing Piquettes struggle with her sense of lacking belonging. This causes the two characters to clash throughout the story in regards to Vanessa's false interpretation of Piquettes identity. Throughout the story Vanessa tends to

Get Access