preview

Analysis Of Two Kinds Short Story

Satisfactory Essays

Including “Two Kinds” in a larger novel changes the ending of the short story when read alone. Read alone, the ending is satisfying as June sits down to play the piano. As part of the novel, the story is just a piece of how these women interact with each other, and with how they interact with the main plot of the novel. The ending also changes again when you consider how much of Tan is in June. Like June, Tan is also a second-generation Chinese-American. Tan also dropped out of the college her mother chose for her. Perhaps most compelling is that the idea for The Joy Luck Club came after Tan discovered that her own mother, like June’s, had been previously married and had children living in China. While there is no way to know for sure if …show more content…

According to William Nelles, author of “Microfiction: What Makes a Short Story Short?”, states that “that a generic distinction may be drawn between short stories and microstories on the basis of six key narrative elements: action, character, setting, temporality (especially duration and order), intertextuality, and closure” (88). These criteria would knock out stories written by O’Connor and Tan because their stories tend to be drawn out and take place over a period of time with more than just one or two characters. For background, “The Blind Man” is set in a bustling town, revolves around one man, and takes place in one day. The Blind Man is going door to door selling pencils and other knick knacks, trying to make a living, while various neighbors pretend they are not home or tease him. This all comes to a standstill at the end when a wealthy business man is killed in a car accident that happens as the Blind Man is crossing the street. Every seeing person around the Blind Man is horrified, but the Blind Man does not even realize what is going on.
Nelles goes onto say that the way the narrator is presented has an effect on the story as a whole. He writes that “The shortest stories must also…rely on omniscient narration, which involves “features favorable to brevity” (90). Because the man is blind, the only reliable point-of-view available is the one of the unseen narrator. The reader can only see what the

Get Access