preview

Analysis of Defining the ‘American Indian’ by Haig A. Bosmajian

Best Essays

Analysis of Defining the ‘American Indian’ by Haig A. Bosmajian

“One of the first important acts of an oppressor is to define the oppressed victims he intends to jail or eradicate so that they will be looked upon as creatures warranting suppression and in some cases separation and annihilation” (Bosmajian 347). The writer, Haig A. Bosmajian, begins his essay with these words in “Defining the ‘American Indian’: A Case Study in the Language of Suppression.” In his essay, which targets mainstream Americans, he attempts to show his readers how language has been used in American history to “justify” the oppression of the American Indians. The use of language …show more content…

This piece of evidence strongly supports Bosmajian’s point about redefinition because it provides a first-hand account of the horrors, as opposed to a second-hand account, where the account would be considered less accurate, and therefore, less reliable. Also Bartolome de las Casas is an outside observer, a bystander, of these horrors, which makes his account more unprejudiced, and therefore more trustworthy, because he is neither the oppressor nor the oppressed. The shock value of this piece also helps in making the argument more unprejudiced, and therefore more trustworthy, because he is neither the oppressor nor the oppressed. The shock value of this piece also helps in making the argument more persuasive since it appeals to the emotions. The reader becomes disgusted and horrified at the acts described in the eyewitness account, and this reaction pushes the reader to see how redefining the American Indians into “savages” can lead to such acts (Bosmajian 348).

In the natural-religious redefinition, Bosmajian also includes statistics and several historical observations to

Get Access