Analysis on The Rush from Non-Judgment by Theordore Dalymple Essay

going on. The father was not there to protect the kid he was in and out every day and he did

Besides performing a botched abortion on his daughter, he was also allowed custody of his daughter, despite that the fact that there is the suspicion of abuse. In the case of Samantha Deo’s abortion, it could be argued that if she lives in a state with many rights of consent for minors, even some as old as twelve years old, it could be argued that Samantha Deo could get an abortion or aids for contraception without her father’s consent (“An Overview of Minor’s Consent Law”). In this case, she would have been able to have less complications due to a botched abortion without needing her father’s consent. We could also draw a lot of parallels to Faust v. Johnson (1998), which examines whether there should be greater rights for minors as well as custody between separated or divorced parents (Faust v. Johnson). Being that the description mentions Daniel Deo is the custodial parent, we could assume that he is the primary parent. Since there is evidence of abuse, not unlike Faust, Samantha Deo should have greater rights as a minor, because she is aware of the fact that she is being abused and since she is older, she should have more influence on which parent has custody. This was not unlike the child of Faust and Johnson, who was aware that he was not emotionally well off with his mother, was more knowledgeable about medical problems than some adults, which resulted in his influence of living with his father

The central issue upon which the Supreme Court based their decision was in regard to the best interests of the child. They looked closely at the nature v. nurture argument, ruling that her psychological parents, the Racine’s, were capable of providing a healthier environment than her biological mother, Mrs. Woods. When looking at this case from a solely legal perspective, it is clear that the Court made the correct choice, considering Mrs. Woods’ ongoing battle with substance abuse coupled with her abusive relationship. However, this case, as with many could not be looked at simply from a legal perspective. Complex cultural aspects are embedded within the case that had to be considered in order to properly gauge the decisions and the effects of that decision. In the past, children were automatically placed with their biological parents or relatives, which, was viewed as standard procedure within the legal framework. Societal norms have progressed in such a way that allow for a more activist

Read “The Rush from Judgment”. Explain how the miseries discussed in this chapter are partially caused by what Dalrymple calls “the absence of either fear or hope, only the present moment…you do what is most amusing, or least boring, at each passing moment.” How does this “eternal present” idea make his patient’s lives worse?

The Father may not see himself or his decisions as selfish or cruel because he thought it was in the best interest for his child. While from a parents perspective this is a noble thing to do protecting their offspring. In the world they are living death is more suitable then live. The father is forced to do things he wouldn’t normally do “from the moment the father

The introduction begins with quotes from people who mention that fathers get women pregnant and then leave the woman and the child; they mention that men need to realize their responsibilities do not end with conception. The book summarizes these quotes as unwed fatherhood is one of the leading social problems, and these men are irresponsible and “hit and run.” A CBS special report, The Vanishing Family, was an interview of McSeed, a father of six from four different women. In the interview, he says the responsibility of raising the child is on the mother, not him.

Michelle knight is a 34 year old Caucasian women who was born April 1981, later on moving to Cleveland Ohio where she was raised (Knight, 2015). Growing up she recalls not having a good relationship with her mother, she remembers “a chaotic childhood marked by neglect and abuse” (Connors, 2014). In school she was bullied and eventually sexually assaulted “By a group of males “resulting in her dropping out of school and later finding out her had become pregnant as a result of the assault (DURANTE, ROBSON & WARREN, 2013). Soon after she gave birth to a baby boy she named joey, when joey was around two years old he was taken to the hospital and treated for a broken leg, Michelle stated that her mother’s boyfriend purposely did it while under the influence of drugs. (Anderson, 2013).Child protective services was called and joey was temporarily taken out of Michelle’s custody until further notice (Anderson, 2013).

One popular example is the case of Neville & Neville [2007] where there was a dispute on who had custody of the child. The courts ruled that since the child had a ‘strong emotional connection’ with the mother, that she was to live with her mother but also share substantial time with her father as both shares equal parental responsibilities. However, the best interest of the child is not necessarily what they personally explicitly want, as shown in the successful appeal by the father in the case Moose & Moose [2007]. In a situation such as this, despite the children apparently afraid of their fathers ‘sexual abuse’, the courts decided that a once- monthly visit in a supervised contact centre would be beneficial as he was a ‘person who can advance their welfare’ and that such a connection ‘should not be severed’. Such a decision may be deemed as questionable due to the severity of the claims.

Due to problems arising out of bitter divorces, custody, and support battles fathers are ostracize out of their children’s life. Fathers are often looked at as the bad person when things go wrong and being the blame. Fathers are just as responsible for the child being born as the mother. Over the years fathers continue to fight for equal rights, mothers are looked at as the victims and often make false statements about the fathers to suit their own selfish needs. Accusations of sexual and child abuse by mothers of the noncustodial fathers are often found to be untrue.

Daughters of non-institutionalized mothers are more vulnerable and they are at high risk of sexual abuse and molestation from the family members and the external world. At the same time they are always in the shadow of verbal and physical abuse of the sick mother. They are not even safe inside the family. These girls are unable to raise their voice, nor protect against abuse. They are facing multiple barriers from the family and the society. It was mainly hidden behind the four walls of the house. Those within the family and the victims did not wish to speak about it.

According to Ives, “…to be a father-as-carer a man has to take on a variety of social roles. The roles associated with the father-as-carer includes disciplinarian, breadwinner/provider, guardian, moral compass, sex role model, guide and friend” (Ives 78). To have a father-as-carer in an offspring’s life gives a woman no reason to disregard the male’s thought. Females that have control over her decisions in sexual acts should not only acknowledge her point of view, but also the fathers. The woman is consciously aware of the outcomes of intercourse when willingly performing in such an act. In “Rethinking Roe V. Wade” Manninen states:

Women that push for an abortion do not always have a partner that agrees and supports their decision for terminating the pregnancy. If the father is willing to support and care for the fetus, it is wrong for a woman to go against his wishes and follow through with an abortion. For a father to want to be involved in the fetus’s life means he is willing to take on the responsibilities of having a child so he should have a say if his fetus should be terminated or not. The Becoming A Father/Refusing Fatherhood article states, “To be a father-as-progenitor a man simply has to provide the sperm that leads to conception, whereas to be a father-as-carer a man has to take on a variety of social roles. The roles associated with the father-as-carer

False judgment leads to crazy notions. It creates false ideas and opinions. Judgment stretches or condemns the truth to be less that it is. In Barbara Kingsolver's novel, The Poisonwood Bible, many characters judge others based upon preconceived stereotypes. 'Judgment is always influenced by stereotypes and causes false feelings'.

The sociological and medical models are similar as the reason for abusing the children is that they don’t know any other way; a parent with medical issues may not understand that it is wrong to abuse their children or that they may not be able to control their own problems and so lash out

Some courts and social service workers are unable to identify signs of child abuse and child abuse that goes unnoticed can create some very violent outcomes. This can be best shown in the cases of Jacob Ind and Nathan Ybanez, two juveniles in Colorado, who killed their parents. Both Ind and Ybanez were abused physically, emotionally, and sexually by their parents. When Jacob Ind’s older brother went to social services to ask them to help his brother, they didn’t even open an investigation into his report. As a result Ind continued to suffer abuse at home until he couldn’t take it any longer and he killed his mother and stepfather.