preview

Analyzing Donald Kovis The Invidious Nature Of Competition

Decent Essays

On September 13 2009, a gathering took place in which many of the most influential people in our generation met, The MTV Video Music Awards. This award show is a ceremony in which MTV, a cable channel, acknowledges the music videos produced in that year by famous artists. That night, as the presenters announced that the winner of the best female video award went to Taylor Swift, the crowd went wild: fans were crying, peers were standing, but one man in particular decided not only to stand, but also walked on the stage, took the microphone out of the winner’s hands during her acceptance speech and interrupted her. “Yo Taylor. I’m really happy for you, I’m going to let you finish, but Beyoncé had one of the best videos of all time” said Kanye …show more content…

Kovis believed that the negative aspects resulting from the bad behavior due to competitiveness outweighed any good that could be created from competition. One of the negative consequences of competition that Kovis went on to talk about is the labeling of a “loser”. This labeling is more common than anyone would like to admit. Competitors might taunt or tease this labeled student, sometimes even resulting in physical confrontations. These rivals lack communication and helpfulness towards one another, which leads to mutual negative attitudes. As conflict escalates and tensions rise, an unhealthy and hostile environment is created. “I’m a pretty good winner. I’m a terrible loser. And I rub it in pretty good when I win” said Tom Brady, an American football quarterback for the New England Patriots, on an interview when describing himself. Mr. Brady is a perfect example of a sore loser/winner. In competitions people have the need to beat their competitors. Once that concept is embedded in their brain, it becomes some people’s day to day. Life becomes the real competition, and peers become rivals: it is not enough for them to be their own best, but they must be better than the …show more content…

This research comes from many departments, but it was mainly from sports, education, the performing arts, and psychology. The results were consistent: competition results in reduced satisfaction, poorer performance, and less creativity. Alfie Kohn, an author and lecturer in the areas of education, parenting, and human behavior, wrote a book in which he compiled 388 research references in which cooperation proved superior to competition, called No Contest. In one example, a meta-analysis of educational studies, which combines the results from multiple studies in an effort to increase power over individual studies, concluded that learning is achieved more effectively in a cooperative environment rather than a competitive one. Competition has a negative effect on productivity and excellence, due to increased anxiety, inefficiency and little inner motivation. Also, it causes people to evaluate themselves on how they measure up to others, creating or increasing their low self-esteem. Although many people are surprised by this, scientists have repeatedly verified that cooperation has proved superior to competition in hundreds of studies since the late

Get Access