preview

Ca's Involvement In The Juvenile Justice System

Decent Essays

According to Rind et al, childhood sexual abuse has received a considerable amount of attention from mental health professionals, politicians, law enforcement, and the media. The general consensus is that childhood sexual abuse causes long lasting, detrimental effects on victims. However, Rind et al conducted a meta-analysis examination of assumed properties of child sexual abuse using college samples that refuted the previous claim. The study ignited a firestorm of controversy in psychological and legislative communities; instigating criticism and the intense review of their findings and applications.
One finding highlighted by Rind et al. stated “for all symptoms but one, CSA participants as a group were slightly less well-adjusted than control …show more content…

Many of the victims were never treated clinically, and do not present clinically depressed, anxiety-ridden, or suffering from an eating disorder. However, many of them present or self-report symptoms of PTSD; including nightmares, flashbacks, intrusive thoughts and debilitating fear. Even more, all of the CSA survivors exhibit some degree of externalizing behaviors; drug use, truancy, poor academic performance, promiscuity, or high risk behavior indicative of Conduct Disorder. It should be noted that their involvement in the juvenile justice system is usually a result of a relatively minor infraction, and not a chronic delinquency issue. This fact would support Dallam’s findings, since the population includes a more “average” …show more content…

While negative effects manifest differently in females than males, the abuse is equally damaging to both genders. In my experience, most male CSA victims are riddled with feelings of guilt and shame. Most often their abuse was perpetrated by a trusted male during a critical time in development. Although the sexual contact was unsolicited and unwanted, their body had a physiological response to stimulation. This confusion often contributes to the victim’s belief that the abuse was somehow their fault, therefore “causing an unwillingness to admit to being victimized, and difficulty making negative attributions regarding an otherwise positive person” Ondersma et al.). Rind’s utilization of a college sample excludes the aforementioned male CSA victims. Since their maladaptive behaviors often lead to addiction, delinquency, and poor academic performance, males who suffered more maladaptive effects are very unlikely to be included in a college sample. Therefore, Rind’s findings can’t be accurately generalized to the majority

Get Access