History speaks of war, the larger picture is told. The story were young men go out and fight for their country. It speaks of those who had to leave- not those left behind. History rarely addresses that people were left behind. Both Kareen from Johnny Got His Gun and Jennie Shenandoah were left behind when their significant other went to fight in the battles of war. For this and many other reasons Kareen and Jennie are comparable along with their situations. Jenny and Karen were both left behind by a loved one and apart from them for significant time. In Karen's case for the continuation of Johnny Got His Gun after the train scene. Both girls went through the struggle of giving a loved one to the cause, and accepting that their love interests …show more content…
She struggles to allow Joe go off to battle, and tells him to run away with instead in attempts to pressure him into not going off to battle. Before Kareen and Joe spend the night together, Kareen says, “... oh Joe I wish you’d run away and not go” (Trumbo 34). She does this because she is terrified of her life without Joe, and worried for Joe’s safety knowing the odds that he’ll come back alive. Along with this she once again tells him not to go the next day during the train scene, “Don’t go Joe run away they’ll kill you and you know it I’ll never get to see you again” (Trumbo 37). While attempting to bargain so he won’t leave. This shows the hesitance Kareen feels about Joe leaving to fight, as she knows it is unlikely for her to see him again- and if they were to see each other, things wouldn’t be the same as they are now. Though never clearly stated, Kareen carries her father's opinion on fighting in the war. She believes that those who fight in the war are fools in the sense that the government the soldiers are fighting for don’t care about individuals, but rather numbers and statistics. It is not the war of foot soldiers, but rather that of …show more content…
When the movie Shenandoah, starts Sam is already fighting in the war, however he doesn’t go off to battle until only seconds after their wedding. Jennie is displeased and saddened that Sam must leave her at this time to go fight, and worries about him greatly- just as Kareen worried for Joe. Though Jennie doesn’t ask Sam not to fight, one must assume that she has thoughts of discouragement toward his involvement of fighting for the confederacy. This is of course because her family does not believe in the owning of slaves. Jennie follows in her father's footsteps knowing that this war is not theirs to fight regardless that they live in confederate land. After being a part from Jennie for the majority of the movie, Jennie and her family find Sam locked away on a train for prisoners of the
When he was little his mom died, and his dad remarried to a woman named Thula. Thula did not like joe and she kicked him out when he was only ten years old. “She declared that she would not live under the same roof as joe, that Harry must choose between him and her. She said Joe would have to move out if she were to stay in a godforsaken place. Joe was only ten years old” (Brown 86,87). I never could understand how someone could kick a child out of the house and force them to live on their own when they are ten years old. As Joe grew up the more he needed his family, but his family was not there for him, at least not his biological family. When Joe made the rowing team that's the day that he got a new family, even if he did not know it at the time. So was Joyce, a beautiful girl who loved joe and they were going to get married and start a family of their own. “When joe stopped playing they talked about what it would be like when they were married and had a hoe and maybe kids” (Brown 102). Making the rowing team and meeting and falling in love with Joyce might have been the best thing that has ever happened to Joe. As soon as everything start going good for Joe, Thula gets an infection and dies. Not that it was a good thing that she died, it was very sad, but it brought Joe and his dad back together again. Harry wanted Joe to move back home with him and the kids. “I’m going to build a house where we can all live
A women’s life in the south during the war was not easy. Women had no rights. Their husbands had to go away and most likely their children. Harriet Tubman is a great example of women trying to make a difference. She was one of the first women brave enough to stand against slavery.
One way the authors argue against war is it tears families apart. “No, you’re going to get yourself killed. Well you might as well. Let’s have it all done with at once. How does the old line go? Men must fight and women must weep, but you’ll get no more tears from me. I’ve done my weeping for this war.” Mrs.Meeker is basically saying she’s over the war, and does not want anything to do with it. Tim and Mrs.Meeker are having an argument, which is showing how their family is broken. “They can murder who they like, church who they like, but I’m not going. For me the war is over.” This line from the book says it all. That quote is the thing that shows a broken family. Not going to see your son one last time before
It is obvious that Ryan is scared of him, “… When I look over my shoulder, Joe Bush will be outside, staring through my bedroom window..” pg. 168 and later “He’ll be watching me leave so that he can go of the dredge ahead of ne and wait for my arrival” pg. 168. The second time they see Old Joe, is when Ryan fell, at this moment Sarah left her camera behind and in the blurry footage Old Joe limping in for of the camera.
Sally Thomas family is given an opportunity to make a name for herself by being given social and business opportunities. While the southernmost states have a different outtake on slavery, Sally and her family are treated with much more respect. Sally is able to own her own business as a laundress and comes to be popular in the town for her kindness and fairness.
Johnny Reeves is a very important character in the story the Witness. Johnny Reeves was a minister for the Klan, and was very active in the Klan’s activities. He was very involved and proud to be in the Klan until he got kicked out for “messing” around with a schoolgirl. After he was kicked out of the Klan, he was abused by the Klan, and no longer was a fan. I argue that Johnny Reeves has seen and heard the most out of any character in the story the Witness because he was in and out of the Klan, he associated with people in the Klan, and he has experienced the good and bad of the Klan.
In this historical text, Reluctant Witnesses: Children’s Voices from the Civil War, Emmy Werner retells the events of the Civil War through the eyes of children who are male, female, black, and white. Werner worked to sift through the reactions and experiences of the young men and women who were involved in the Civil War. Each chapter articulates a different portion of the battle and the events during the Civil War. Chapter two, five, six, eight, and nine capture the eye-witness accounts from young soldiers and young women who lived through the Battle of Shiloh, the Battle of Gettysburg, the siege of Vicksburg, the burning of Atlanta, and Sherman’s march to the sea. Chapter three, four, seven, and ten depict the responses the young children had at Andersonville, during the bread riots, the triumph at Washington D.C., and the voices of the former slaves of the south. Werner thrived to increase the knowledge on the involvement of children within the Civil War. Werner’s historical picture was to present the realities children faced on and off the field of battle. Werner’s argument focused on children’s perspective of the Civil War. She supports her claim by providing diary, letter, and journal excerpts from one hundred and twenty children ages four to sixteen, by being focused on their subjective experiences of the hardships they endured and how they managed to cope with them drawing, where appropriate, parallels to the experiences of children in contemporary civil strife.
He does not understand why his own mother would do such a thing to him. During this moment, Joe begins to transition from precociousness to the confrontation stage. After he kills his mother, he is confronted by Shola, who tells him that his mother is good and she is not the devil. Joe arrives at the Church with his mother’s body being carried in his arms. He lays her at the alter and begins to pray for forgiveness and to say his final goodbyes. His father rudely suggests that he removes Nunu’s body from the church. Joe’s will for his mother and his emotions got the best of him when he confronted his father about the truth and him being his child. Joe was intensely outraged and sat the church on fire burning himself and his father. At the moment of Joe’s death, Joe was in the internalization stage of black consciousness. Joe began to have positive attitudes about his mother’s culture and beliefs.
He had to relocate her, but he finally knew what he must do to keep her safe. In a particular example, Amber’s intricate plan was to stash Liz in the Blacksmith’s shop—in town (214). The interaction between Joe and Amber was about the location of Liz. Joe has heard some information that Amber has been safe housing Liz from EB. In another example, Amber lied to Joe about Liz’s whereabouts because he knew there is a bounty out for Liz’s capture. Amber knew in order to protect her he had to lie to Joe (228).
As opposed to communicating his outrage he tries to avoid panicking. This is either an indication of incredible resilience or utter shortcoming. There, on the other hand, is a moment when Joe demonstrates that his pride has been harmed, to be specific when he leaves the coin under his wife's cushion in the wake of laying down with her. This is a sudden turn in an identity that is apparently unequipped for harming someone else. Anyhow who can accuse the poor man for he has seen his entire world go into disrepair after the treachery of his loved one. The integrity of his character is completely shown in his pardoning toward the end of the story.
Esther Hill Hawks, M.D. is one of the many women that decided to stay away from the battlefields in order to support the Union Army. She and her husband were well to do doctors that worked in a hospital that took in and cared for black soldiers. On one day Hawks was to expect over five hundred wounded soldiers.
“I thank God that I can say on my death bed that I am a virtuous woman” (Belle Boyd). Isabelle Boyd was a very brave woman during the Civil War which was from 1861 to 1865 and was the bloodiest battle fought on American soil. She was born on May 4, 1844 in Martinsburg, Virginia and died on June 11, 1900 in Kilbourn, Wisconsin. Belle Boyd was very influential to the Civil War because she was a spy for the confederacy, a messenger to Thomas J. “Stonewall” Jackson, and fought when she needed to, even if her life was threatened. Life as a spy
But as the chapter goes on that characterization of Joe soon changes. On pg 43 we see the first sign of Joe changing because of his newfound mayorship. It states "Thank you fuh yo' compliments, but mah wife don't know nothin' ...
A sequence of events leads up to Joe becoming almost completely isolated from the outside world. During his time in the isolated continent, Joe becomes addicted to narcotics; he escapes his pain and anguish by succumbing to detached and paralyzed state of mind. Throughout his journey in this secluded continent, he is faced with his hatred of the Germans and his desire to enact vengeance upon them for all that he has lost. When he meets a German geologist exploring the frozen tundra, he inadvertently kills him. Joe experiences ironic feelings of remorse after so many years spent obsessing over the destruction of the Germans. There was no gratification or fulfillment, for Joe, in the German man’s death. Joe felt repulsed and an abhorrence in himself for his
On March 25th, 2017, I interviewed Charlotte “Putse” McCarroll who was born on June 3rd, 1935 in Cyrus, Minnesota. I asked her about her life and experiences during WWII. She doesn’t recall much about the actual War. She was a 4-year-old child during the start of the War and was in grade school when the War ended. She didn’t have any family members that she remembers actually being in the War. Putse told me that while the war was occurring she just stayed at home or went to school. She kind of remembers gathering around with her family and just praying for it to end. She said that life was very different because everyone was scared and no one knew what was going to happen. She thought to herself that anything could