preview

Charlotte's Web Of Power Struggles Essay

Better Essays

Charlotte’s Web of Power Struggles: An Examination of the Character of Charlotte in Royall Tyler’s The Contrast Tina Turner once sang, “What’s love got to do with it?” Within the song, Turner’s answer to this question is to focus only on her feelings of attraction, thus rejecting any romantic feelings. The same question can be posed to the concept of marriage. Marriage might seem easily definable: a legal union of two people. However, the motivations behind marriage differ across cultures. In America marriage is often linked with the idea of love. However, the idea of marriage as a bond of love is specific to Western culture. Additionally, marrying for love is a fairly new idea. Historically various cultures, many European, used marriage as a political tool. In this way, marriage was about gaining …show more content…

Charlotte’s repentance for her Eurocentric behaviors, such as attacking the character of others to try and gain power, symbolizes her shift from Eurocentric to American values. Maria’s response to Charlotte’s apology firmly solidifies that transition, as Maria tells Charlotte, “You have all of my love” (1447). Maria, by giving Charlotte her love, is giving Charlotte what Tyler implies is at the core of the American ideal: love. Manly’s immediate response, “And mine.” further emphasizes this shift within Charlotte’s character and the strength of the American ideal, for though Maria and Manly give Charlotte all of their love, their love for each other is not diminished (1447). Additionally, Manly’s final lesson, that “probity, virtue, [and] honour will secure to an honest American the good graces of his fair countrywomen,” can be applied directly to Charlotte (1447). By recognizing her faults and apologizing for them honestly, Charlotte secures the good graces of Maria, the fairest countrywoman of the

Get Access