preview

Compare And Contrast Westing Game Movie Vs Book

Satisfactory Essays

“It’s not what you have, it’s what you don’t have that counts.” (Raskin, p. 43 ) Mysteries go out of their way to try and confuse the reader. The Westing Game by Ellen Raskin is no exception. In the past two months, GLMS sixth graders have tried to solve the murder of Sam Westing. After reading the novel, students then watched the movie version. The movie really used the “don’t have” portion of the opening quote by eliminating many details. The Westing Game book and movie contain many similiarities and differences that are worth exploring.

Body Point 1 (Bectel) The Westing Game story centers on an aging industrialist searching for an heir. Sam Westing, by creating a game, is able to find the one person smart and tenacious enough to …show more content…

The Westing Game movie had many differences from the book. The first detail the viewer of the movie notices is the change in the Sunset Towers setting. The book had it as a brand new building with one-way glass on the shores of Lake Michigan. This setting was designed to show the rise is social stature for the new tenants, especially the Wexlers. Grace, in the book, was always concerned with upward social mobility. On the other hand, the movie portrayed the building as being rundown and in the heart of a bustling town. The Sunset Towers was also home to a coffee shop and doctor’s office in the lobby and Chinese restaurant on the 5th floor in the book. Because of changes or removal of characters, the movie had no doctor’s office or coffee shop and the Chinese restaurant was on the first floor. Many of these changes were a result of characters being left out of the movie that served a prominent role in the book. The Westing Game novel used eight pairs of heirs to work on solving the murder of Sam Westing, but the movie only used five. The paired heirs were put together in the book to help each other grow as people. For example, Denton Deere was a self absorbed intern who only was concerned with himself. His partnership with the crippled Chris Theodorakis allowed him to grow and change into a caring human being, while Chris was presented opportunities for new medications to control his disability. One of the biggest changes from the book to the movie was the normalization of the Grace Wexler character. The book portrayed Grace as a social climbing snob only concerned with the marriage of her oldest daughter, Angela. Her second child, Turtle, was ignored and the result was Turtle kicking the shins of many people. With the elimination of the relational element in the movie, Flora Baumbach, a new mother figure in the book, was not needed so Turtle was

Get Access