preview

“Compared with the ‘Market-Outsider’ Model of Corporate Governance, the ‘Relational- Insider’ Model Is Associated with Superior Employment Relations”. Evaluate This Statement with Reference to at Least Two Countries

Better Essays

“Compared with the ‘market-outsider’ model of corporate governance, the ‘relational- insider’ model is associated with superior employment relations”. Evaluate this statement with reference to at least two countries.

There are many different ways to categorize national systems of corporate governance. Gospel and Pendleton argued in their book, Corporate Governance and Labour Management that national systems of corporate governance can be divided into two different models (Gospel and Pendleton, 2005:7). They are the ‘relational-insider’ model and the ‘market-outsider’ model (Gospel and Pendleton, 2005:7). Gospel and Pendleton argued that different corporate governance systems would influence management behaviour and decision-making …show more content…

For instance, “ninety per cent of listed companies in Germany have a shareholder with at least a 10 per cent stakes in the company” (Vitols 2001:342). The second feature that differs between the two models is the market for corporate control. In the ‘relational insider’ model, large firms tend to use market forms of financing. A significant amount of capital can be raised from public equities and market debt. Investors hold well-diversified portfolios and it is easy for them to exit an unprofitable company by selling their investment. An active market for corporate control can be achieved through hostile takeovers, mergers and acquisitions (Gospel and Pendleton 2005:7). By contrast, in the ‘relational- insider’ model “large owners have a more stable and direct relationship with management of the firm, but where smaller investors and the market for corporate control exert less discipline” (Gospel and Pendleton 2005:7). Thirdly, the primary corporate goal in the two models is different. In the ‘market-outsider’ model the primary goal is maximization shareholders’ value. In the ‘relational-insider’ model there are multiple goals including employment security, market share, and profitability (Vitols, 2001:339). Finally, Companies in the ‘relational-insider ‘model pay more attention to employees’ interests while in the ‘market- outsider ‘model shareholders’ interests are placed above all other stakeholders. For instance, in a

Get Access