Comparing A Midsummer Night's Dream and Romeo and Juliet Essay

First, Hermia went through many different issues and conflicts throughout the story. Hermia was put in the situation of being forced to marry either Lysander or Demetrius. They both loved Hermia, but Hermia only loves Lysander and despises Demetrius. Egues comes to the decision of Hermia marrying Demetrius. Hermia states “If then true lovers have been ever cross'd,It stands as an edict in

Comparing a play to its movie adaptation is something that is hard to do since there is no tangible way a person can capture the original then change it to make the movie version of it up to par to the original. From the original play of A Midsummer’s Night Dream that was created by Shakespeare in the movie version of it created by Michael Hoffman, there are many similarities and differences that are in the movie some are very stark while others are very subtle differences.

Tragedies explore the downfall of a main character with a doomed fate.The play Romeo and Juliet written by the playwright William Shakespeare and the film adaption directed by Baz Luhrmann use imagery to make the audience aware of Romeo and Juliet’s doomed fate. Both texts explore the story of two lovers whose destiny was to end up together dead in the afterlife. In the print version, William Shakespeare illustrates the significance of imagery through the recurring symbols and motifs of stars and light and dark. In the film version, Baz Luhrmann demonstrates the significance of imagery through the recurring symbols and motifs of religious objects and symbols as well as water.

Hermia makes her animosity towards these stereotypes of women known throughout the entire play. When Hermia is treated as an object that her father “may dispose of” if she does not marry Demetrius (1.1.42). She decides that this is the last straw and does not want to be treated like this anymore. Egeus decides he should continue to insult his own daughter by saying he “should be as a god.../one to whom [Hermia] [is] but as a form in wax” meaning that without Egeus, Hermia would be nothing and he is the reason she is the way she is (1.1.48-50). This is when she decides to run away with Lysander. The first night in the woods after Hermia and Lysander run away with one another, Lysander pushes the idea that he and Hermia must sleep with each other

Of the two versions of Romeo and Juliet that we watched in class, I believe that the Luhrmann version was more compelling since it better conveyed the plot with a story and setting that is much more modern but helps one understand the plotline better. When the two houses are visualized as more of gangs and mob bosses, it helps one in modern day remember and associate the plot with current events. In the Zeffirelli version of Romeo and Juliet, while the setting was much more realistic to what Shakespeare most likely visualized, the story was much more bland in my opinion due to the lack of intriguing elements in it. Because of the way Luhrmann directed the film in addition to its setting, it makes for a more compelling and memorable story.

Romeo and Juliet was an inspired story by the myth “Pyramus and Thisbe”. Each story has many similarities and differences. An example of how these two stories are similar are how they had fallen in love with their families enemies and how much they were willing to sacrifice. An example of how these two stories are different are how each of them had died for the other person. There many similarities and differences between these two stories.

Romeo and Juliet’s families were fighting. There was three things and or people that got in the way of Romeo and Juliet. The two families named the Capulets and Montagues contributed. Mercutio taking Romeo to the Capulets party also contributed. The Friar and his three plans contributed to Romeo and Juliet’s passings too. The two families fighting, Mercutio taking Romeo to the party, and plus Friar Lawrence with his three plans contributed to the passing of Romeo and Juliet.

It’s true that Juliet in Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet and Neil in the film Dead Poets Society have dissenting voices that challenge existing values and beliefs. Dissenting is a word that means to disagree with something and have a different opinion from most people. Both Juliet and Neil are dissenters in the texts; they have their own opinions from their families and have the courage to disobey their parents. Both texts demonstrates the tragedy inherit in stifling human desire and idealism. Both texts also demonstrate the power of tragedy to force and oppressive.

To make a long play short, Hermia loves Lysander, but she is supposed

Egeus tells the Duke that his daughter can marry Demetrius, not Lysander. Hermia replies ". . . If I refuse to wed Demetrius," Egeus replies "Either to die the death,

A Midsummer Night’s Dream by William Shakespeare was written in either 1595 or 1596, Romeo and Juliet was written a bit earlier but also published around 1595. In Romeo and Juliet, two star-crossed lovers are torn apart by the prejudice of a family feud. At the end of the tragedy, the suicides of these two lovers mends the age old hatred between their parents. In A Midsummer NIght’s Dream, a comedy, a forbidden love obstructs a father’s marriage plans for his daughter. His daughter and her true lover make plans to run away, which are hindered by their friends, who have equally passionate but conflicting loves, as well fairies who play tricks on their hearts.

The Romeo and Juliet (1968) movie had some differences with the original play, although I did enjoy watching it. Watching the film also made me understand some parts of the play a little bit better. A detail that stood out to me the most, however, was how ridiculous the servant’s livery looked like. It almost appeared to resemble a jester’s clothes. I also like how the film took out some parts of the play they deemed unnecessary, but some parts of the play that were added were confusing.

This demonstrates that when Egeus tried to control Hermia by telling her who she is going to marry, Hermia took action and decided

Disagreements about dating and marriage often occur between parents and their children. Hermia especially had this issue with her father. Egeus, Hermia’s father, disliked Lysander, because he states “With cunning hast thou filched my daughter’s heart,” ( I,i,37) by this Egeus

In the play, the reader can see their weaknesses as a couple when they encounter obstacles along their adventure of love. Lysander and Hermia love each other a lot. If they were able to, they would get married in Athens. The unstable relationship of Lysander and Hermia is important to A Midsummer Night’s Dream because it displays Shakespeare's theme regarding that love can be difficult. Egeus plays a big factor in Hermia and Lysander’s relationship. In the first scene it is shown that Egeus commands Hermia to marry Demetrius instead of Lysander. Hermia’s freedom lies in the hands of Egeus, because in old athenian time, a man would need the approval of the lady’s father in order to get married. Hermia has to choose between remaining single, marrying the man of her father’s dreams, being taken to a nunnery, or being executed if she were not to follow her father’s orders. Hence, the hardship of their love faces the threat of human death. The fear of separation haunts Hermia and Lysander, should Hermia decide to protect her life by not marrying the love of her life. Demetrius and Lysander argue over who should get to be with lovely Hermia. Egeus gives