preview

Contradiction In Scarlet Letter

Decent Essays

Though Hester has repented for her sins and has worn the scarlet letter for nearly a decade, she is still an outcast in her society. Even when she has become a force of good around her town, "Hester's nature showed itself warm and rich; a wellspring of human tenderness, unfailing to every real demand" (158), it seems there is nothing she can do to disprove the harsh judgement that arrived when she took up the scarlet letter. Technically, she has done everything in her power to make up for her long-past sin. In reality, the people around her treat her as if she were the only sinner in the town and had done nothing to correct her past wrong.
This contradiction between what the Puritans supposedly believe and how they carry out those beliefs Hawthornes method of showing that the Puritanical society is dysfunctional and hypocritical. …show more content…

Though the parameters of sin are outlined based on religious beliefs, they are acted on in a purely personal manner. This is what creates a difference in the viewing of sin between the majority of society versus Hester and Pearl. Hawthorne is arguing that the actions that should be considered sins are those that are done so by Pearl. When she rejects Dimmesdale even though earlier, “Pearl, twice in her little lifetime hath been kind to me[Dimmesdale]." (203). However, "Pearl would show no favor to the clergyman." (208) because Dimmesdale would not admit to his sin and stand with Hester and Pearl on the Hawthorne is using Pearl’s elevated sense of understanding about people to show that she can determine when a person’s action should really be considered a sin. The fact that she accepts her mother, but rejects her father, shows that Hawthorne believes that Hester, after repenting, has redeemed her soul while Dimmesdale, after lying and cowering from everybody, is far more of a sinner than Hester ever

Get Access