Can Deception Be Good? A Look at Deception and Trickery in Much Ado and Sir Gawain Perception is important in Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing as well as in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. Although the writers come from different time periods, they share ideas on the concept of deception. Shakespeare was writing to audiences who lived in the Elizabethan time where nobility and social classes were important. In fact, “During Shakespeare’s time there were only about 55 noble families in England (Elizabethan). Appearances were important to his audiences in social society. During the Gawain poet’s time period of Arthurian Romances and stories of chivalry, appearances were equally important in society. The concept of deception has been around since Adam and Eve, and in most instances, it is seen as negative and often harmful. Both authors produce characters who have problems perceiving reality from appearances and in many instances are deceived by appearances. Shakespeare and the Gawain Poet both use trickery and deception as a plot device to create conflict in both works and promote the theme of appearance versus reality. Uniquely, both authors use deception to better the main characters by the end of the works and at the same time, the deception allows the reader to consider moral choices. One way to make the audience or the reader question perception is to create a visual deception. Shakespeare and the Gawain poet use disguise to create visual deceptions in
Deception is defined as “the act of tricking someone by telling them something that is not true”. In the play, Macbeth by William Shakespeare, deception is always present and things are not always what they appear to be. In this great work of literature, the three witches; the Thane of Cawdor; and Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are the very embodiments of trickery and show us the true effects deception can have on man.
In this world rumors and dishonesty happen to be everywhere, no matter where you are. Nowaday people start rumors just to hurt and insult people’s feelings that later on lead to dramatic events. In the story “Much Ado about Nothing”, we encounter different scenes that lead to rumors and deception. One scene that we encounter is when Don John, the bastard brother spreads rumors about Hero being disloyal to Claudio and Don Pedro to corrupt Claudio’s and Hero’s relationship. Another scene that we run into is when Ursula and Hero have a talk in the garden about how Benedick has love affection towards Beatrice. Later on, these two scenes play a huge role and become dramatic elements of the story. We will encounter on how rumors and dishonesty
In Shakespeare’s Macbeth, a selfish Scottish thane becomes over-ambitious and commits several murders in order to gain and stay in power. After the murders, Macbeth evades suspicion by hiding his guilt and intentions, therefore deceiving others into thinking that he is innocent. Other characters including Lady Macbeth, the witches and the Scottish thanes also use their appearances to hide the truth and deceive others. With these examples, Shakespeare shows that appearances can be deceiving.
Human nature is often considered in isolation from the rest of the world as if it would be an exception or a special case. In Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing, the complexities of human nature are explored in depth. This essay will explore in particular how Shakespeare dramatises the concepts of human misunderstandings, deception and dichotomy through effective dramatic techniques.
Not All Can Truly Be Seen: An Analysis of the Impact of Blindness and Deception in Othello
A central theme in the play Much Ado About Nothing is the appearance versus reality portrayed through characters. Throughout the play characters are in a constant battle of showing their hidden truths or withholding their faulty appearances.
believing in the illusion is more satisfying and comfortable. In Shakespeare’s work there is a
In Hamlet deceiving illusions are frequently used to protect truth from being a destructive force. Situations within acts one and two that appear to be true and honest are really contaminated with evil. Various characters within the first two acts hide behind masks of corruption. In the first two acts most characters presented seem to be good and honest making it a complex task for Hamlet to discover all the lies that have hidden objectives within them.
In Much Ado About Nothing, Othello, and A Winter’s Tale, William Shakespeare shows the shift in which in which perception becomes knowledge. As a thing becomes known, through one sense or another, it is filtered through the mind, and then emerges as knowledge. Shakespeare examines this process, focusing on the ways in which we unconsciously influence the formation of knowledge. Much Ado about Nothing, Othello and A Winter’s Tale each explore different sides of jealousy which all stem from the same problem. All believe their innocent wives to be unfaithful. However, since everybody experiences reality differently, due to our own bias, we can never be certain that we understand anyones perspective. Claudio, Othello, and Leonates attempt to compensate for this uncertainty by assuming the absolute worst about their wives with only the absolute minimum of evidence. Unfortunately, their conviction that such assumptions are correct leads to disaster.
Shakespeare in his comedy, Much Ado About Nothing, opens the audience up to the notion that a dedication to the truth can be nearly impossible. Delusion, deceits and ploys are common place in the city of Messina. But they are not exclusive to the setting of Shakespeare’s play. Shakespeare is introducing the idea to his audience through the characterization of all of the characters as well as the unfolding plot that it is becoming increasingly difficult to perceive and recognize the truth. Along the same lines, until a person has come to know themselves, in all their quirks, strengths, weaknesses and has even come to accept themselves and love themselves as they are it will be ever more challenging for them to decipher reality from illusion.
Each of the main characters in Much Ado About Nothing is the victim of deception, and it is because they are deceived that they act in the ways that they do. Although the central deception is directed against Claudio in an attempt to destroy his relationship with Hero, it is the deceptions involving Beatrice and Benedick which provides the play's dramatic focus.
Pressure between our own opinions and the social constructs of our communities often leads to internal conflict. In the play Much Ado About Nothing, written by William Shakespeare, several main characters experience this dilemma. This tension can severely damage relationships with others, as it does for Leonato, Beatrice, and Dogberry. Through this lighthearted play, Shakespeare reveals how internal conflict can blur the line between love and hate, causing disorder in relationships with others. Due to Dogberry’s incompetence in his job as constable, he often feels tension between his self consciousness and the expectation from the citizens of Messina.
Noting, or observing, is central to many of the ideas in Much Ado About Nothing. The word nothing was pronounced as noting in Elizabethan times, and it seems reasonable to presume that the pun was intended by Shakespeare to signal the importance of observation, spying and eavesdropping in the play. As a plot device, these occurrences propel the action and create humour and tension. The perils of noting incorrectly are portrayed and this leads naturally to the investigation of another major theme, the discrepancy between appearance and reality. Shakespeare uses the problems of illusion, deception and subjectivity of perception to examine the Elizabethan patriarchy, and he shows
Part Three of the tale is the peak of Gawain’s obstacles in the form of the Lady Bercilak. He is repeatedly tested in a psychological game of chivalry against courtesy. To Gawain, the Lady Bercilak is even “Lovelier than Guenevere” (line 945), his own queen, so it is no doubt that the challenge imparted upon him by her attempts at seduction is a great one indeed. In addition, Gawain also must compete in Lord Bercilak’s game of trading each day’s winnings for the winnings of the other
Deceit and lies are rampant in William Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Hamlet. It can be seen in the characters’ actions and words, as well as what they fail to say and do. It comes in various types of relationships -- between husband and wife, parent and child, siblings, and between lovers. Nearly every character in the play either deliberately spins a web of their own lies, uses another person for their trickery, or is used in another person’s deceitful plot. Each has different motives for their deceit -- to maintain power, to achieve their goals, to attain vengeance, or simply because it is necessary to function in this twisted society -- but all of them face a tragic ending no matter their initial intentions. In this play, deceit is so uncontrolled, intertwined, and multidimensional that it becomes impossible for either the characters or audience to ascertain what is true.