preview

Defining Community

Decent Essays

Defining Community

What makes a community? To get a better handle on this question, it may be useful to analyze a specific encounter between the individual and his community(s). Let's take, for example, the much-publicized soccer match between Mexico and the U.S. in the summer of 1996. This game received a great deal of media attention because, even though the match was held in Los Angeles, on U.S. soil, the vast majority of fans were cheering for the Mexican team. The U.S. team members, on the other hand, were greeted with a chorus of boos and were pelted with various objects on the field. This trend in urban areas of largely Hispanic support for the teams of other countries was hardly new for U.S. soccer; the players and coaches …show more content…

Implicit in this reaction is our assumption that individuality and community are inversely proportional. The French sociologist Emile Durkheim seems to support this view:

. . . there are in the consciousness of each of us two consciousnesses: one which is common to our whole group, which . . . is not ourselves, but is society living and acting within us; the other represents us at our most personal and distinctive, in everything that makes us an individual. The solidarity that derives from similarities is at its maximum when the collective consciousness completely envelops our total consciousness . . . but, at that moment, our individuality is nil. 1

He describes the relationship between individuality and community as a zero-sum. Durkheim argues that we can become more collective only insofar as we sacrifice our individuality and vice-versa. And if we agree that the relationship between individuality and community is a zero-sum, is there a feasible balance between the two? Or must we shy away from community of any type because of the risk that our individuality will become nil?

I would like to suggest, in response to the original question, "What makes a community?" that we become a community by virtue of asking the question rather than by any particular answer to it we give. Our community-by-collective-self-interrogation depends on setting almost nothing beyond

Get Access