preview

Essay about Discriminatory Rhetoric in Athletics

Best Essays

On April 15th 1947, Jack Roosevelt Robinson played his first game for the Brooklyn Dodgers. Jackie, went without a hit in a game which would have been noted only in sports almanacs were it not for the color of his skin. At Ebbet's Field that day, Robinson broke baseball's “color barrier.” The integration of Black athletes into White mainstream sports had begun. Robinson endured a variety of slanderous yells, racial epithets and even hurled objects. The fact that African Americans would be discriminated against in sports was never more apparent. Today, that same vitriol manifests itself in various forms of discrimination. Rhetorical forms of discrimination are just as damaging today as outright bigotry was then. Though rhetorical …show more content…

Black players, however, are most often credited with an innate physical ability (687). To a viewer at home watching a sporting event it might seem that all a broadcaster is doing is trying to compliment players in different ways. Blacks are blessed with god given talent; Whites are hard workers. Herbert Simons, UC Berkeley, argues that this seemingly innocent attribution is far more detrimental than one might think: describing athletes this way, “reinforc[es] a contemporary form of social Darwinism... [called] race logic. According to race logic, intelligence is more developed than physicality on the evolutionary scale” (17). According to race logic theory, to be gifted with intelligence shows that an individual or group is more evolved or more advanced than an individual or group that relies on physical prowess. Physical prowess consists of a more base form of evolution that is more concerned with matters like hunting and survival. Simmons contends that the assertion that a White athlete is more intellectually gifted than a Black athlete is the equivalent of saying that the Black athlete is not as evolved. The unchecked rhetoric of sportswriters and broadcasters, analyzed under the lens of Social Darwinist theory, concludes that a White athlete's supposed ability to think quickly and intelligently places him on a higher evolutionary plane. This plane is one which physically gifted Black athletes do not regularly attain in the rhetoric of sportswriters

Get Access