preview

Dodd Frank Pros And Cons

Decent Essays

One of the current topics in financial news concerns regulatory legislations and specifically the Dodd-Frank act that was enacted after the 2008 financial crisis. As with most regulatory legislations, there are both pros and cons with proponents to each side. I find the current arguments similar to the issues surrounding the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 that was enacted after many financial accounting scandals in the late 1990s. While many believe both pieces of legislations make the financial markets safer and more transparent, there needs to be a balancing act to allow capitalism to also flourish in a free economy.
a.) Provisions to Eliminate: To enhance a more capitalistic economy, I believe some of the more burdensome provisions that hinders …show more content…

Under this rule, banks are once again limited to the type of trading they can conduct and it prohibits them from trading and speculating activities (Tracy, Ackerman). I tend to side with the critics of this rule and as it hinders a bank’s ability to benefit from available opportunities. Through this provision, we have taken a direction towards the Glass-Steagall Act where banks were forced to separate their investment and commercial segments (Investopedia). Within this provision, it also prevents banks from investing in hedge funds. By eliminating a whole class of investments, I believe this rule is too overpowering without adequate evidence to back up this claim. While some hedge funds have been cited for taking too many risky tactics, there are also a lot of hedge funds who do an exceptional job hedging out risk and eliminating large losses. As we found in our research for our presentation, hedge funds can provide many diversification benefits if properly used and can oftentimes avoid the heavy losses associated with a market collapse. Therefore, I do not believe there is a sound basis to restricting an entire class from banks to choose from. I also agree with House Representative Jeb Hensarling from Texas who argues that these rules should be scrapped in favor of a higher capital requirement (Tracy, Ackerman). I believe this would be an easier policy to implement and less costly to regulate while also allowing banks more freedom to pursue profitable

Get Access