preview

Edna as a Metaphorical Lesbian in Chopin’s The Awakening Essay

Decent Essays

Edna as a Metaphorical Lesbian in Chopin’s The Awakening

Elizabeth LeBlanc places The Awakening in an interesting context in her essay “The Metaphorical Lesbian,” as gender criticism must, for Chopin wrote the novel at the end of the 19th century, when homosexuality as an identity emerged culturally, at least in terms of the gay male identity, as proffered by Oscar Wilde across the Atlantic. Lesbianism, too, started to make its debut on the cultural stage, particularly in literature. However, although lesbianism started to emerge during Chopin’s lifetime, it seems doubtful that it played any formative role for Edna’s characterization. Yet gender criticism often requires a reading of a text in light of gender and sexuality regardless …show more content…

In contrast to a more feminist perspective, LeBlanc views Grand Isle not as a female colony but as distinctly patriarchal. The fact that mother-women seem to rule enhances this reading according to their own submission into the phallogocentric demands of the island and culture beyond. The island visitors’ rejection of Mademoiselle Reisz, a woman who fails to conform to the expectations of a heterosexually normative society (and a woman who is, according to LeBlanc, culturally coded to be read as nonheterosexual), underscores the supremely heterosexual patriarchy that dominates Grand Isle.

LeBlanc wisely steers clear of placing Edna in a lesbian space, choosing instead to place Edna as “something other, a fascinating creature who stands apart and resists definition” (242). For LeBlanc, Robert is the traditionally feminine man on the island who mirrors Edna herself; thus Edna appears to select a person who represents the masculinized encapsulation of herself, which represents woman-woman identification. However, here I disagree with LeBlanc, for although Robert is admittedly feminine or unmasculine, I believe masculinity to be a gendered niche that patriarchy must create for itself out of the markedly, fixedly feminine sphere (an idea or hypothesis I am seeming to create in my own work). Thus Robert decides instead not to appropriate those qualities that femininity possesses for a greater masculinity, but instead enters

Get Access