preview

Essay On Baby Doe

Good Essays

It’s April 9th, 1982 and an expectant family is preparing to welcome a beautiful baby boy into the world. It is an exciting, joyful, and nerve wracking experience as the parents enter the hospital. Everyone is hoping for the best and praying that everything will go perfectly. After hours of labor, the child is born, however, something is wrong. The care providers are rushing around and blocking the view of the baby until a doctor comes in to explain that your baby’s life is in danger. The baby is severely disabled and needs extensive medical care to survive. The family is faced with a choice, put your child through endless and painful medical procedures that many not work or decline treatment. The choice is yours, what would you do? This …show more content…

This can lead to choking or death (Rose, 2004). A child born with any of these conditions could require extensive life long treatment with many obstacles for the family to overcome. The parents of Baby Doe were faced with a choice. They could have the baby undergo a surgery to mend the esophageal atresia, which was given a 50% chance of success, or they could choose to not treat and let the baby die (Majumder & Bruce, 2014). Unfortunately for the parents, the doctor’s opinions varied, which would have made their decision even more difficult. The family was given three opinions from the obstetrician, pediatrician, and primary care provider. The pediatrician and the primary care provider urged the family to treat the child and potentially save his life. The obstetrician stated they should simply keep Baby Doe comfortable and feed him. Although there were two opinions to try and treat the child, the family decided to follow the obstetricians care plan and forgo the surgery. Due to the decision, Baby Doe had to be cared for by a private nurse because none of the nurses wanted to follow the care plan that was established for Baby Doe (Rose, 2004). After the parents’ decision to deny treatment, the pediatrician decided to take the issue to court in hopes of having the parents’ decision overturned and provide treatment to Baby Doe. The case started in the Indiana’s trial court and at the end of the trial the judge decided that the decision belonged in the

Get Access