According to the NEA (National Education Administration), one of four Americans says students should be paid for good grades. (Flannery) Paying students for good grades is a topic that has been talked about over a span of multiple years. Should students be paid for good test scores, doing homework, and completing assignments on time? Students should not be paid for the grades they get at school because when rewards are given the student loses the interest in learning itself and focuses solely on the reward, a student's character growth can be a better motivator than money, and at a young age children don’t understand the use of the money they would earn for the grades they received which can highly ineffective.
First, when a student starts
…show more content…
When a student thinks about the rewards he can get from good grades instead of growing as a person can negatively affect them later in life. “ For example, personal growth is one of the main benefits of learning in a classroom with fellow students, which should be payment enough for children (Breed). As shown by the example, when a student can grow as an individual when completing school work should be a better reward than money for the student. Furthermore, an example is shown in Matt Breed’s article when he states, “Some “jobs” serve not as money making opportunities, but as character and experience builders.” This is a great example because it shows that personal growth is more important than money for an internship or volunteer work in the real-world just like in school when someone would get money for good grades. To summarize, when someone is to give money for grades they are missing the most important thing for the student which is personal growth in themselves which can lead to far better rewards than money will.
Finally, money for grades should not be given because children at a young age don’t fully understand the importance of money. “ Children do not fully understand the importance of earning money and often don’t really need their own money,” (Breed). Children at a young age can receive money and not know what to do with it or they wouldn’t care about it as much as playing a video game rather than
If students are rewarded for quality schoolwork, grades may initially improve. They may show more excitement. However, in the article “Why You Shouldn’t Pay Children for Grades” by Amy Mccready, it is found that the enhanced grades deteriorate along with the excitement for the payment. Most children simply lose interest in the reward. It is better to just let youth accomplish
First off, school requires a mental effort which by definition is considered to be work. Since we go to school for 8 hours every day and do that about 180 days per year, we should get paid if we keep our grades up because it’s hard to do. Keeping good grades requires lots of hard work and effort. It also requires time, which some of us
School is slave labor. Rather than enjoying or learning from their classes, students are forced to do useless work that will often be forgotten immediately. Grades are meant to show much a student understands a class, but instead are used as a scale of how well a student can regurgitate answers onto a test. Students only work for good grades because of the threat of being punished for failure, and the promise of reward for passing. The punishments in this case are detention or trouble from teachers, and the rewards are making the honor roll or getting bragging rights. The real reward for learning should be having new knowledge, but this is not taken into consideration. Jerry Farber, a professor at U.S.D, made the strong claim that grades are useless and harmful in his essay, “A Young Person’s Guide to the Grading System.” I wholeheartedly agree with Farber’s objection to our current grading system.
Giving your children money for satisfying grades that they get doesn't benefit them with their career that they will have as adults. Let me back this up. If they get paid for the super grades that they received they will soon have an expectation that everything good that they do they should receive something in return. This makes kids not try to the best of their ability because these children know
The article “Why You Shouldn’t Pay Children for Grades” was written by Amy McCready. McCready explains that parents should “inspire a love of learning, cultivate good habits and allow children to plot their own course, they will truly flourish.” Throughout the article McCready provides reasons that serve as evidence for this main idea. McCready explains that school is not just about grades, but also about how well children develop key skills for later in their life. Also, McCready explains that children will not be rewarded for every job well done in the future, and if parents continue to pay for grades children will expect a reward for everything they do well.
Why kids should not get paid for good grades In america parents should not give kids money for grades. First of all if parents give their kids money for grades then the kids won’t learn anything later on because they will only care about the money not school and it will affect their learning. Lastly parents should not ever give their kids any money for good grades if they do that is a very bad idea.
One time, I got a good grade and my grandma gave me money. If school is truly wants student to be motivated to do well in the school should pay student for a better grade. Motivate student prepares them for high school higher test score. From better graduation rates for learning about work making kids smarter there are many positive effects of paying student for a higher grade.
As in many cases, scholars have different insights about the issue of offering money for high grades of school-age children. There are always parents who go for this idea and motivate their children then . While another group of parents believe that it is not good and this action will make their children dependent on the reward. They claim that such approach will not help their children in future. My own stance delinatesdelineates with the first group. It could be a very good idea if parents make some motivations for their children as they are studying. Because in today's competitive world, education plays an important role in children's future. So parents must try their best to make their children study well.
“Why can’t our hard work have an income?”. Almost all students have had a similar thought at a time in their lives. To them, the incessant striving and vassalage they do for school deserves a salary. However, the situation with the exchange of grades for payment is a problematic state of affairs. In the predicament of schools giving students this opportunity, it will certainly lead to catastrophic events for all parties involved, especially, in the long run. Insightful to the statistics and evidence of both standpoints, school payment for grades is a situation best abstained because it causes quagmires. In agreement with this, say it causes conflicts, it’s only short-term, and causes negative impacts in the long run. By not paying students, you avoid turmoil, cut out a short-term motivator, and allow their future selves a better chance academically.
To begin with, students should not be paid for exceptional grades, as a result it robs their feeling of accomplishment. According to “Parents paying their children money for excellent grades is a horrible idea”, by Gisler and Eberts, “ Many parents don’t realize that giving money to children for grades robs their feeling of accomplishment.” This means, giving children money they only do their work if they’re getting paid, and they don’t learn as much. The effect of this is that they don’t get that feeling of them doing their work all by themselves with nothing supporting
Carol Dweck is a psychology professor at Stanford University who recently conducted an experiment on how students receive appraisal. This is what she found,
Kids should get paid for good grades because they will start reading more, in a school in Dallas, TX. They start to pay two dollars for each book kids read, they actually became better readers, they started to understand things better, the test scores begin to get highly raised up. The other people that are in the opposite side may say that, this is bad for young people and they will became interested and will just want to do the things just if there's money involved and they will, not do it if they don't get payed for what they do, and if they don't get payed or if they get late payed they will go down, but they are all wrong because probably, with all the things that they learn will keep going up. Don't you guys want your kids to subside in school?
What would happen if students are paid? If schools truly want students to learn they shouldn’t pay students for good grades. Paying students for their grades can lead to lower academic performances. In addition, the students who are getting payed will dampen their natural enthusiasm for learning. It also gives kids unneeded pressure extra pressure. Paying students for good grade is a bad idea because they will have lower academic performances, their enthusiasm will dampen and students will have unneeded extra pressure.
It is another morning and your child is getting ready for school. If schools truly want students to be motivated to do well in school, then the schools should be willing to pay students for their hard work. Schools should do it because there will be higher graduation rates, prepares them for the real world, and higher test scores. Why should students have to work for nothing, they are basically doing a job. From better graduation,to preparing kids for the real world, to raising up scores, there are many effects of paying students for getting good grade.
Should students get paid for getting good grades? Yes because then students will try harder and do better in their classes. Test grades can improve also if rewarded. This also gives students convenience and something to work for. It can also give students a little look at what it’s like to have a job, because they would get paid for their hard work. It could make students fell good about themselves knowing that their hard work is being recognized. Students should know that their work is appreciated and noticed that would give the student convenience and appreciation.