preview

Ethical Case Study : The New Nurse

Good Essays

Ethical Case Study According to the scenario given in example 2, the new nurse on the unit is facing an ethical dilemma by being asked to violate the code of ethics. This scenario regarding the preceptor telling the nurse to violate policy and chart that blood draws were done correctly is violating provision 3. Specifically, if the nurse interjects and decides to not draw the blood cultures too close together and from the same site, it upholds provision 3.5 Protection of patient health and safety by acting on questionable practice. The American Nurses Association code of ethics (2015) states, “Nurses must be alert to and must take appropriate action in all instances of incompetent, unethical, illegal, or impaired practice or actions …show more content…

4.3 states that nurses are accountable for their actions and can accept or decline specific tasks based on their knowledge for the sake of professional practice (American Nurses Association, 2015). The nurse being told to do the blood draws incorrectly has the option to step back and review the policy. If he or she does not feel comfortable, the nurse then has the option to decline performing it incorrectly. The nurse has to look out for the patient as well as themselves while taking responsibility for what they chose to do or not do. Provision 5.4 Preservation of integrity applies to scenario 2 because the nurse has the right to protect his or her integrity and not compromise it. The nurse is solely responsible to uphold integrity and cannot blame mistakes on others. The ANA Code of Ethics (2015) states, “Such threats may include requests or requirements to deceive patients, to withhold information, to falsify records, or to misinterpret research aims” (p. 20). By having the nurse reflect upon the provision at hand, it is clear that falsifying records violates this code. When discussing the principles and definitions of ethics, the terms beneficence, fidelity, and justice are demonstrated within this particular scenario. Beneficence is described as the will to do good for the sake of the patient as well demonstrating compassion (American Nurses Association, n.d.). The nurse can practice beneficence by looking out for the

Get Access