preview

Examples Of Justice In The Crucible

Decent Essays

“Justice is not always just” can be the essence of the dramatized Salem Witch Trials in Arthur Miller’s play, The Crucible. One of the most dramatic and mesmerizing scenes in the play involves John Proctor. Proctor is a farmer in his thirties who is married to Elizabeth Proctor and has three boys. He does his best to avoid the Salem Witch Trials hysteria driven by Abigail Williams until his wife is accused for witchcraft by the court. Unfortunately, Proctor finds the same faith as his wife in an attempt to free her because Mary Warren, his servant, accuses him for manipulating her through witchcraft. Like many other victims including his wife, he is sentenced to death unless there is a confession made. Proctor originally refuses to confess, …show more content…

Danforth committed various types of logical fallacies against Proctor and possibly other victims. For instance, during Proctor’s confession, Danforth asked Proctor “Will you tell me now what persons conspired with you in the devil’s company?” Danforth asked Proctor a load question in an attempt to fool Proctor into admitting his crime and ruining his reputation. In addition, Danforth uses false dilemma such as “You will sign your name or it is no confession” and “You will prove your whiteness or you cannot live in a Christian country” to repeatedly pressure Proctor for the same purpose. Danforth as the judge of the court uses logical fallacies to manipulate his victims into coughing out what he wants to hear. Miller uses logical fallacies to further disprove the trustworthiness of the court and add on to the list of evidence that shows corruption in the Salem Witch …show more content…

For instance, Proctor’s stage direction and his response to Danforth’s question is “Crying out, with hatred: I have no tongue for it.” The response sets off an emotional tone that deeply touched Parris and Hale, therefore they jump in to help Proctor out by persuading Danforth to let him sign his confession. Additionally, as an effort to fight for his name, Proctor argues “God does not need my name nailed upon the church! God sees ny bane; God knows how black my sins are! It is enough!” to Danforth who needs his confession paper. Proctor in the quote above struggles for Danforth to spare his name, he is desperately trying to appeal to Danforth’s emotion and hope for the best. Miller formulates these quotes above to give the scene life because it instills distress, a feeling that people would experience in a real court. Without tone, Proctor’s struggles would not be as impactful to the readers as them did in the

Get Access