preview

Executive Compensation

Better Essays

Case Summary

In 1993, Michael D. Eisner of Walt Disney fame received $203 million as executive compensation. Although this award was inflated by Eisner 's exercise of stock options, many examples of compensation in millions and tens of millions raise questions on how CEOs should be paid. Critics dispute that CEOs are deserving of their pay. CEOs downsize companies or perform badly, yet continue to draw a substantial salary. Unlike low level managers, it seems there is no formula for executive compensation. The disparity between the executive pay in US and that of in other industrialized nations is great, furthering the belief that there is no rational (?) basis for compensation. Among sports and entertainment figures, there exists a …show more content…

Thus, the Board of directors is the main decision maker in this ethical dilemma.
Public

The public would benefit from a booming American economy with the brightest talents taking the helm of various enterprises. Customers and suppliers would enjoy the stability and continued existence of major companies that they deal with. Thus, having a sufficiently high executive compensation would ensure that talented individuals are attracted to the field of management. However, if the disparity between the pay of the executive and the average employee is too high, this will lead to a serious income gap which could contribute to social problems. Indeed, it has caused public scrutiny into the fairness of executive compensation. The American increase of its Gini coefficient from 0.34 in the early 1960s to 0.47 in 2004 demonstrates this concern (United Nations University, 2007).

Analysis using Ethical Theories

Are US CEOs fairly paid? Do they deserve the pay that they draw?—A combination of perspectives of Libertarianism, Aristotlean Justice, Utilitarianism and Kantian Ethics will be used to analyse these questions.

In reference to Disney 's $203 million executive compensation, the author of the case in Boatright (2007) asserts that no one can be worth that much in any just economic system.

According to Aristotle 's ideas

Get Access