preview

Giorgio Agamben Magic And Happiness Analysis

Good Essays

The concept of happiness has eluded philosophers and intellectuals since the beginning of mankind’s ability to reason; though many have attempted to create overarching theories regarding the phenomenon, all have fallen short of grasping the dual nature of its formation: both demanding of hard work and of faith in some higher, seemingly transcendent force. Giorgio Agamben’s piece “Magic and Happiness,” an excerpt from his work Profanations, is no exception. The passage argues in favor of a belief in “magic,” a divine and all-encompassing force that presents, in his opinion, the solitary path towards true happiness. His argument, formed around the notion that persistent effort and achievement ultimately cannot yield happiness in the long …show more content…

Instead of spending copious amounts of time researching for a doctorate in chemistry, one could easily redirect that time towards watching television or doing things that are much more comfortable. It is only logical that people forego this comfort in life in pursuit of something infinitely more important; said doctoral candidate presenting his/her thesis would do so with much more satisfaction and true happiness with confidence in the fact that he/she invested assiduously as opposed to having it all dawn upon him/her in one divine, magical experience. Simply put, a rational actor pursuing happiness would invest time logically into things most important to him/her; the fruition of those efforts is more likely to create happiness and emotional validation. Furthermore, Agamben’s erroneous implication that self-awareness of happiness is correlated with a god-complex-like hubris fails to take into consideration the connection between happiness and humility; this correlation is crucial because it allows one to take ownership of the happiness he/she earned. The text poses a bold claim that “ [w]hoever enjoys [happiness derived from magic] escapes from the hubris implicit in the consciousness of happiness, since… the happiness that he knows he possesses is not his” (Agamben). In making this statement, Agamben makes himself clear:

Get Access