preview

Good And Good Life In Plato's Life Worth Living?

Good Essays

which are not well lived ( Pg 80). Here Plato makes the powerful correlation between the knowledge an orthodontist has acquired and the knowledge a philosopher acquires. He states that the knowledge an orthodontist acquires is as complicated as the knowledge of what distinguishes between good and bad action, and lives that are worth living ( pg. 84). Therefore, just as Dr. Kolondy is the expert on teeth a Philosopher is an Expert of what makes for a good life. Plato believes that because the knowledge that differentiates good and bad actions requires “extensive expertise” than only those who have spent years mastering this complicated subject should be able to advise ( pg 85). He believe that to accurately determine a life worth living it takes someone who is set apart from that life and can assess that life from a vantage point. Cheryl counter interjects Plato’s above statements by saying, “ Who are these Philosophers to tell people how to live?” I asked him in no uncertain terms. Who are they to tell me how to live? It’s my life, and I think I know what makes it supremely worth living, to use your phrase, better than any expert in philosophy does ( Pg 85).” Cheryl’s main argument is that no one is born knowing how to live. Through experience and moral values people develop a life that they deem worth living. A worthwhile life to someone is different to another. Cheryl continues her stance by saying that because it is our right to make this choice freely no one has the

Get Access