preview

Goodbye Columbus And The Great Gatsby

Good Essays

Throughout American history, there are cases in which American authors have been influenced by the the distinctive aspects and beliefs of a particular era. More specifically, F. Scott Fitzgerald's’, The Great Gatsby, and Philip Roth’s, Goodbye, Columbus, are two novels that embody the American culture of their own eras, within their own novels, through the relationships of their main protagonists. In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald captures the “Roaring 1920s” in New York through Gatsby and Daisy’s his protagonists, relationship. Fitzgerald emphasizes the rebellious, impulsive qualities of the 1920s, and the belief that the way to fit in was to maintain a rich, successful upper class life. While in Goodbye, Columbus, Roth shows the post-war era …show more content…

Roth’s accompanies his portrayal of the determination during the post-war era with the view that maintaining a stable income and lifestyle was seen as successful. Although Fitzgerald’s Gatsby and Daisy’s relationship and Roth’s Neil and Brenda’s relationship are separated by 30 years of different aspects and beliefs of American culture, both relationships are obsessive, materialistic, and superficial.
In The Great Gatsby, Nick Carraway, a friend of Gatsby and Daisy, describes the three aspects that lead to the end of Gatsby and Daisy’s relationship. The narrator, Nick, infers that Gatsby is obsessive about rekindling his romance with Daisy when he describes Gatsby as having “been full of the idea so long, dreamed it right through to the end, waited with his teeth set, so to speak, at an inconceivable pitch of intensity,” (Fitzgerald 92). Nick uses the word intensity to represent Gatsby’s actions of buying a house across from Daisy’s house and throwing elaborate parties waiting and hoping for Daisy to attend them. Aside from Nick’s concerns about Gatsby’s obsessive behavior, Nick finds the …show more content…

Unlike Gatsby’s obsession with repeating a past romance, Neil’s concern of Brenda indifferently ending their current summer romance is indicated during a suspenseful game in the pool where they each took turns disappearing in the water. When Brenda resurfaces after a long absence and hugs Neil, Neil recalls that “I would not let her go” and I told Brenda, ‘That's it Brenda. Please, no more games,’ I said, and then when I spoke again I held her so tightly I almost dug my body into hers, ‘I love you,’ I said, ‘I do.’" (Roth 53-54). Neil’s forceful hugging displays his physical need to hold Brenda within his arms and not let her drift away from him. Whereas Gatsby and Daisy use materialism to force romantic feelings, Brenda and Neil use materialism to ensure that their relationship is meaningful. In the beginning of Goodbye, Columbus, Brenda admires Neil body and compliments him on his shoulders and overall physical structure (Roth 18). Eventually, she reveals to Neil that “I’ll sleep with you whether you do or not, so tell me the truth” (Roth 51). Brenda proves her materialistic desire to use Neil’s body for sexual pleasure rather than to use his intangible feelings to create a meaningful relationship containing affectionate love. Although Brenda is not fascinated by expensive objects,

Get Access