preview

Hamilton Case Summary

Decent Essays

The issue in this case is whether the state of Hamilton should dismiss the charges on the basis of the insanity defense? The Petitioner, Lee Wang was charged with two shoplifting crimes. The first crime was stealing a $2.00 bracelet from Macy’s Store and the other crime was stealing a $100 watch from Lord $ Taylor’s Store. In fact, Lee lived a bad childhood. Her father was extremely verbally and occasionally physically abusive. During committing the crime, Psychiatric affirmed that Lee is suffering from Multiple Personality Disorder and also that what makes her created “the friend” personality.
Indeed, the first thing that we must do in this case is to apply the M’Naghten Rule (Daniel M’Naghten’s Case) in this case to determine whether Wang was sane or insane at the time when she commits the …show more content…

Last but not Least, according to the evidence, I do not believe that the court would ask for further evidence and testimony to dismiss these charges. Through the Psychiatric examination testimony, it would be enough to confirm the innocence of the accused.
In conclusion, The State of Hamilton Court should dismiss both of these shoplifting charges because the defendant is not responsible for their actions due to an episodic or persistent psychiatric disease at the time of the criminal

Get Access