preview

Hamper's Rivethead Summary And Analysis

Decent Essays

Weeks 13-15 in this Michigan History course seemed to focus a lot on the behaviors of certain groups and who should be blamed for these behaviors. Week 13’s discussion board was considering whether or not students believed that Hamper’s Rivethead was an appropriate book for a survey course in Michigan history. Week 14 covered who or what should deserve the most blame for the current plight of Detroit, while week 15 students were asked whether or not U.S. authorities have reasonable cause to monitor the behavior of Arabs and Muslims in Michigan more closely than other groups. These are all tough questions where the ethics of students were challenged.

In reading Hamper’s Rivethead, students were able to gain a lot of insight regarding what …show more content…

After doing some research it was learned that in 2012 Detroit suffered 411 homicides. This number was higher than in 1974 when Detroit as designated as the murder capital of the United States (Rubenstein & Ziewaxz, p. 340). Who is to blame for these statistics? Can the blame be placed solely on one thing or certain groups such as the policemen, politicians, teachers, or the economic decline? After much thought and debate, this student came to the conclusion that each individual must take responsibility for his or her own actions. While it would be easier to place the blame on certain aspects of Detroit, there were many unfortunate events and circumstances that took place. As sad as it is this is simply a fact of life and as long as people keep pushing the blame on everyone other than themselves, things will never change. I think that the current plight of Detroit can teach this current generation of Millennials a lot. We can act as entitled as we want and push the blame everywhere other than ourselves, but until we take responsibility for our actions; things will never change for the …show more content…

This was perhaps the most difficult question of the entire course. While it would be easy for me to say that yes, some groups or religions have drawn it upon themselves to be monitored more closely, it does infringe on the very rights that this country was founded on. According to The Terror Decade in Arab Detroit (p. 16) Shryock, Abraham, and Howell explains that “Arabs of different national and religious backgrounds often have widely divergent understandings of the War on Terror.” By reading these articles one learns that the most dominate Muslim group in Michigan are Shi’a Muslims. This is the conservative Muslim group who are against Al Qaeda and their extremist’s beliefs (The Terror Decade in Arab Detroit p. 3). Again with this discussion question, there is no easy

Get Access