preview

Hard To Be A God: A Messy, Murky Masterpiece

Best Essays

Derrick Lieu
Professor Porter
Vis 154
9 June, 2016
Hard to Be a God: A Messy, Murky Masterpiece Hard to Be a God, Aleksei German’s hefty three hour film based on a novel of the same name, is grim, shocking representation of a human society without scientific advancement or pursuit of knowledge. In this cinematic depiction, thirty scientists are sent to an identical Earth-like planet where the residents there have had their renaissance and scientific enlightenment periods completely suppressed and anything considered remotely “intellectual” is destroyed and so society was forced to be frozen in the Middle Ages indefinitely. At the beginning of seeing this film, I was bored and unimpressed by the experience. The setting was always …show more content…

The readability of Hard to Be a God is partly assured by the sense its implied reader has of being ‘in the know.’ The disguise and secrecy essential to allegory invest its hidden message with a rhetorical power it would not necessarily possess on its own (Gomel).” The decision to interweave these parallels and minute details into Hard to Be a God to make it possible to draw these allusions to actual historical events makes it immensely more powerful and imaginative as an allegorical film appealing to, in this case, the Soviet intellectuals who were capable of reading more in-depth into the text. It’s form as an allegory and a film naturally lends a sense of responsibility and power to the audience to perhaps not just be conscious about the dangers of intellectual suppression and indifferent individuals, but to create an active discussion about these certain topics and cultivate

Get Access