The Tale of Beowulf; the Magnificent.
Upon research I discovered the comparison between the movie and the book contrast severely, however some aspects of the movie are similar. Beowulf is the epic hero- or so the poem makes him seem. He commits acts of bravery, he’s ready to fight, he’s primal, and he’s willing; all the qualities the poem gives to Beowulf. Whether the book or the movie he’s been given the qualities of an epic hero, after all he’s “Higlac[‘s] cousin and [his] king[.]” Nevertheless the way the reader should feel about Beowulf was told different in both poem and movie
One cannot take away from Beowulf’s boldness, and of course his boastful personality- Zemekis’ movie especially cannot take away from this. He can, though, take the epic Beowulf down a couple notches by making him seem like a liar, which is exactly what he did. Yes, Beowulf is still the same character
…show more content…
In the film version, Beowulf talks about his many qualities that make him epic enough, “[but] wasn’t it three” said one of the comrades of Hrothgar after Beowulf just finished talking about the reasons he didn’t win the match between him and Brecca in Unferth’s challenge. Robert Zemekis even changes up the battle (or what we thought would be a battle) between Beowulf and Grendel’s mother by making it seem as if there was a sexual relations between the two them, enough so that Beowulf gets a son. This fortifies Beowulf, as the very flawed hero, which fell for a monsters trickery. In the film version also, when Grendel the first monster (there were three, I checked) first encountered Hrothgar he was portrayed as a gentle giant. The first thing we could obviously
In the book as well as the movie Beowulf brings fourteen men to the land of the Danes and defeats Grendel. The first main difference is that in the book Grendel’s mother only kills one Dane, Aeschere. In the movie Grendel’s mother slays all of Beowulf’s men besides Wiglaf. At this time in the book Wiglaf is not present with Beowulf and his men, but only at the final battle against the dragon. In both the book and the movie Beowulf detaches Grendel’s arm and his mother returns to the hall for revenge. In the book Beowulf immediately follows Grendel’s mother to the underwater lair, but contrastingly in the movie Beowulf would have no knowledge of Grendel’s mother unless Hrothgar would not have told him. Beowulf kills Grendel’s mother and returns to Geatland to rule in the book, however in the movie Beowulf lies about killing Grendel’s mother and stays to rule in Denmark. Just as Beowulf brought Grendel’s head back in the book, he also did so in the movie. The book does not mention that Hrothgar was the son of Grendel or that Beowulf was the father of the dragon. In the book as well as the movie Beowulf defeats the dragon and dies as the hero of the epic even though he did it in a different way at a different place. The concluding difference includes Beowulf’s funeral. The book displays his funeral as a burial near the coast of the sea, but conversely in the movie his body is put on a burning ship sent out into the
Movies and books are never the exact same, sometimes even the whole plot is changed around. In the book Beowulf the plot, characters, and setting are a lot different than they are when the movie was created. If a person watched the movie before they read the book, it may be totally confusing to read. In the book, Beowulf shows up and plans to fight with his men, then leaves to go back to his own kingdom. In the movie Beowulf, Beowulf ends up staying and becoming king of Dane Land.
If we’re going to compare the book to the movie we have to make sure we’ve carefully read the book and watched the movie occasionally stopping your mind to evaluate the movie wondering what is different. I did just that, Beowulf the book compared to the movie has a variety of differences and some similarities. In my opinion the movie was better, let me tell you why.
Beowulf is an epic poem written a long time ago. The 13th Warrior is pretty much a movie based on Beowulf but not exactly. The two pieces of literature both shared a lot of differences and similarities as well. The 13th Warrior offered a more realistic, believable, and more understanding of the epic tale of Beowulf. It’s a short story covering the bases of a triumphant hero battling three supernatural monsters. But there had a lot of theatrical remake of the original story; it provides us with the barbaric cannibalistic tribe of the Wendols, which were creatures of the mist. Both the epic Beowulf and the movie the 13th Warrior shared similarities and differences in the struggle of good
After watching the film, The 13th Warrior, and reading the epic, Beowulf, there are several similarities and differences. The main characters are different, with similar goals, but different reasons for doing what they do. The main idea never truly changes, and is persistent throughout both the film and the poem. The differences in the set up of the film outweigh the similarities, but the similarities of the plot and the general concept are easily noticed.
As most people know a majority of movies differ from their books. Today, due to English IV an explanation will be given for the reasons why Beowulf has been changed. Beowulf is an epic from long ago. Today the truth of what happened in Beowulf is being argued over by Scholars around the world. As an example, medieval eras and ancient times have their myths and rumors spread throughout their history. Dragons, Wizards and Witches are all a part of the Medieval era, but this story is among the eldest. It is unknown if it did happen or not. Nevertheless, proof exists that Beowulf’s Father did exist. The truth may never be known.
Every epic hero possesses certain heroic characteristics. The epic poem Beowulf describes the most heroic man of the Anglo-Saxon times. Beowulf is the hero. He shows that he is a great man by always putting other things before his own needs. He is important and needed by his people and is known by many as a strong, courageous and a helpful person. He shows all of the qualities and traits that a true hero possesses.
In comparing the Beowulf movie to the poem, there are many similarities and differences in gender role, beowulf's heroism to a love life which reflected on anglo saxon and modern society. With both the movie and poem, you would expect to have similarities, but for Beowulf, both had two
Beowulf is portrayed as a hero-figure, though a less-than-ideal leader, since his warrior-like tendencies and habits follow him. Conversely, the movie Beowulf portrays our hero as more of an anti-hero. By its very nature, Beowulf is an epic hero, but I do not think that the movie does not portray him as such a hero compared to the original translation, because it has an entirely different storyline. If anything, the movie portrays Beowulf as a weak person, easily swooned by the beauty of Grendel’s mother. The movie and the book differ in several key ways, including his relationship with the kingdom and his villains. Even though the general plot is the same, when you really take a deep look at the differences, Beowulf’s movie ceases to be a version of Beowulf anymore, but rather an entirely new story about the same person.
Nevertheless, his personality deviates and he was no longer the confident man the Geats had once thought of him. Before Beowulf’s third battle, his qualities diminished, “I’ve never known fear, as a youth I fought in endless battles. I am old, now, but I will fight again” (607). The man
According to the textbook and film, Beowulf acts similar but he has many minor and major differences. When compared to each other, a series of important events can be pointed out including the main characters. The textbook and film is mainly about an overly confident, heroic, brave, and selfish man named Beowulf traveling across the seas to save Hrothgar’s kingdom. It was also about a supernatural legacy of a curse repeating in different forms. In this story, it talks a lot about defeating evil and supernatural beings such as Grendel and his mother. The book and movie about Beowulf shows that Beowulf solves Hrothgar’s problems; however, when compared they show many differences, such as the battle between Grendel and Beowulf, Beowulf and his kingdom, and Grendel’s Mother’s evil acts.
Beowulf was an epic poem about a man battling a ferocious beast: however there is also a movie. The poem/movie were both interesting and takes place in the kingdom of Herot. The name of the killer beast Beowulf happened to battle, was named Grendel. Grendel hated the sound of joy and music. As the people of Herot rejoiced and played music, it caused the savage to attack.
Beowulf does not undergo much character development considering what he goes through. His personality and leadership traits remain static throughout the story unlike most other stories that involve a similar plotline. This both shows great strength as well as the inability to change which is often considered a weakness if this stillness is viewed without context. In the case of Beowulf this primarily brings out his strengths as a hero and allows the story to move at a quicker rate and not focus on character development, but on other aspects of the poem, this being the alliteration and beauty in the writing far beyond the plot itself. Beowulf is a consistently strong warrior that stays honorable through the poem, but just increases his levels of glory through each enemy defeated as well as each year of peace after he attains a full level of sovereignty.
In conclusion there were many different aspects to the book and the movie but one thing is for sure. Beowulf is a good story that wills last generation. No matter how many times it is changed to suite the generations that comes
There are many differences between Beowulf the epic poem and Beowulf the movie. Many things could be questioned about the movie. Why would the people change the movie from the story? There are several things that would accurately answer this. The actual written story was published in 700-1000 A.D. In that time of period there was no copyright, not very accurate handwriting, and understanding. People in today’s society just look at it as their own perspective of view. Today’s modern day people expect more from a character. Why is that? The reason for that is people would get bored quickly. They must show that person is valuable, heroic and brave. It bases of by people’s preference of the types of movies/poems/books they would like to see/hear/read.