preview

Hyperandrogenism Research Paper

Decent Essays

The female eligibility requirements established by the International Association of Athletics Federation and the International Olympic Committee are unethical and discriminatory. According to these governing boards, it is acceptable to prohibit female athletes with hyperandrogenism from competing at sanctioned events. However, according to Katrina Karkazis of the Stanford Center for Biomedical Ethics, these guidelines are unfounded and essentially disbar female athletes who “are (considered) “too masculine” to compete with other women” (IAAF 2011c, 1). These restrictions are sexist and discriminate against female athletes who don’t exemplify the feminine gender stereotype. Sex verification started with the “mass certification of female …show more content…

These guidelines fail to view hyperandrogenism for what it is, an inherent biological variation. In many ways it is no different from other biological differences possessed by some athletes…”such as runners and cyclists (who) have rare mitochondrial variations that give them extraordinary aerobic capacity and exceptional resistance against fatigue…basketball players who have acromegaly, a hormonal condition that results in exceptionally large hands and feet...and perfect vision that exists among baseball players at a significantly higher rate than in the general population. Some elite athletes have variations in the ACE (and NOS) genes, which affects muscle growth and efficiency, and blood flow to skeletal muscles. Elite athletes thus already display myriad types of biological and genetic (variations)” (Karkazis 11). Does this mean that every superior athlete possesses these traits? The answer is no. Then why single out female athletes with hyperandrogenism? Perhaps these actions are based more on society’s obsession with female athletes who exhibit masculinity in any …show more content…

As the editors of a special issue of Sociological Perspectives devoted to gender and sport observed, “Cultural tensions between athleticism and femininity have long been managed by social control or strong encouragement for women athletes to attend charm schools, to wear long hair, painted nails, or other markers of emphasized femininity” (Karkazis 7). The issue of femininity is exemplified by the Williams sisters, who are considered to be two of the best athletes in the world, but are continually barraged with questions and comments about their physiques and appearance. It seems apparent that strong women who refuse to adapt to the feminine stereotype threaten society. Furthermore, femininity is considered the norm and any deviation from that is viewed as nonconformist, which “infers homosexuality. Thus, gender policing in sports is a form of homophobia” (Karkazis

Get Access