preview

Incident Analysis Framework

Decent Essays

The basic research question is that there is a relationship between intoxication, chronic alcohol use, and violent behavior. Another research question that is stated in the article is if this relationship is a causal relationship or if it is actually spurious. Other hypotheses made on adolescents were stated later on in the article. The first one is that the relationship between drinking (prevalence and frequency) and engaging in violence while sober is weaker than the relationship between drinking and violence. The second hypothesis is that the relationship between quantity of drinking and engaging in violence while sober is weaker than the relationship between quantity of drinking and violence and the relationship between quantity of drinking and violence while drinking. The third hypothesis is that adolescents who have a history of prior violence are more …show more content…

The incident analysis did make some statements that are open to ecological fallacy. Ecological fallacy is logical fallacy in the interpretation of statistical data where inferences about the nature of individuals are deduced from inference for the group to which those individuals belong. The incident analysis mainly focused on those who drink. The article stated that those adolescents who have a history with violence may be prone to alcohol abuse. The other unit of analysis is the individual analysis in which it was divided among three panels in order to be studied easier. The panels were violent while sober, violent while drinking, and violent. The study used both cross-sectional and longitudinal designs. It used both designs since it gathered the data from the same objects and it although it had several variables, it didn’t quite find the cause and effect relationship in the purpose of the article. Causal assertions were made. One of the causal assertions that were made was that the relationship is mostly spurious and not exactly

Get Access