preview

Joan Of Arc: Inspirational Or Insane

Better Essays

Joan of Arc: Inspirational or Insane

The figure of Joan of Arc endures uniquely as both a product and progenitor of the medievalistic impulse, mustering its diverse subdisciplines into her service. Rediscovered, and in a sense, saved by nineteenth-century medievalism, her presence in turn, generated and continues to generate further avenues of similar inquiry, particularly in her shifting political associations and inspiring feminist endeavours. Despite Joan of Arc’s incredible achievements as a young woman, the controversial claims of her mental affliction and divine inspiration juxtaposed withs her heavily prejudiced trial continue to overshadow and devalue her status as one of the most significant and influential women in history. In order …show more content…

Joan of Arc: Inspired or Insane. Honors Composition 107. Pennsylvania: Lycoming University) Not to say that medieval and modern historians haven’t attempted to provide an explanation – indeed, there have been numerous attempts claiming to understand the reason and the anomaly of Joan’s ‘voices’, thus affecting the way society perceives Joan of Arc. These ‘voices’ have been interpreted in many ways - according to many medieval sources, Joan was not hearing the divine voices of Saints and angels, she was simply insane – which as a result, resulted in the complete demoralisation of her brave accomplishments. Modern historians however, evaluate these voices psychologically, and use excerpts from her trial answers to try and determine her mental illness. Typically, both medieval and (surprisingly) modern literature exclude the countless courageous endeavours that led to her canonisation as a Saint, and focus on her questionable sanity. According to Joan’s answers during the trial, these ‘voices’ were angels and saints, through whom God was addressing her. Although at first, the ‘voices’ frightened her, she eventually became accustomed to them, and even talked with them. …show more content…

These victories however, were overlooked in her trial – and in order to appease France’s guilt, Charles VII cleared her name and in the year 1920, she was canonised and labelled the patron Saint of France. It is remarkable, miraculous even, that Joan, a 19 year old peasant, who was a woman no less, convince Charles VI to supply her with an army and fight for France. Her desire to fight for France did not stem from violent tendencies however, it was her ‘voices’ that told her to fight for France, as can be seen in her letter to the King of

Get Access