preview

Johnny Got His Gun Analysis

Good Essays

Plato, an ancient Greek philosopher, maintained the theory that “only the dead have seen the end of war.” Plato, who lived from 427 BCE to 347 BCE, experienced a lifetime filled with war and expanding empires. Although Plato remained a philosopher, rather than a soldier, he chose to acknowledge the loss and destruction following war. Plato’s theory of “only the dead have seen the end of war,” means one will see the end of war only in death because if one may survive war, one will never be able to tell when the next shall begin. Both Dalton Trumbo's novel Johnny Got His Gun and Universal's film Shenandoah tell the story of two seemingly different characters, Joe Bonham and Charlie Anderson, who in a like manner, undergo loss and …show more content…

War is a horrible thing to Joe, and it is too late for him to go back and change the outcome. Whatever the reason may be, propaganda works with Joe. Although he is unlikely to find France on a map, he is likely to be able to explain in depth how terrible the Germans are because of propaganda. In Johnny Got His Gun, Joe is not happy that he was tricked into fighting a war that has nothing to do with him. Joe desperately wants to show people what war is really like and what the costs of war can be. One of Joe's primary anti-war attitudes is that war is encouraged by class inequality. This means the working class has a tendency to be the one who faces a greater consequence with regards to war, yet they do not benefit by any means. It likewise implies that the masters of war—those with influence and cash—can wage war at any time they want to because they are not the ones who have to fight (Trumbo 241). It is a rich man’s war, but a poor man’s fight. Joe thinks of the bigger picture: he is saying that one cannot deal with something as big as war without first dealing with the social conditions that make it possible. Joe feels cheated by society because this was not his war and he did not have any reason to join in the first place. In a way, society brainwashed Joe into feeling that this was his war and what war would bring for him. Joe Bonham is

Get Access