preview

Justice In And Then There Were None

Decent Essays

And Then There Were None Essay In And Then There Were None, a murder mystery novel by Agatha Christie, ten guests are invited to Soldier Island by Mr. U. N. Owen. The island is open and pretty much empty with the exception of a mansion that the guests will be staying at. Mr. Owen’s invitees are all inside of the modern house just as a huge storm is rolling through, which traps them on the island and inside the house. The group has just finished dinner and is sitting in the drawing room when all of the sudden a recording from a gramophone starts to play. The voice on the recording charges each of them with a murder, knows the date of when it was committed, and the names of the people who were killed. The guests are disturbed by this information, …show more content…

If a justice system is ruled by only one person and that person has a passion for causing death, it will most definitely be a corrupt and unjust system. This is because even if a defendant is found or thought to be the slightest bit guilty, that judge will order death upon them. Wargrave believes that since he was going to die soon anyway that he needed to fulfil his dream of a perfect murder, but he did not want to harm the innocent. He went out and devised a plan to find people that had gotten away with murder and justice was not served. Then to kill all of those people he chose to follow a nursery rhyme he had loved from his childhood. He did this because he had loved to read murder mysteries and wanted to make the whole plan theatrical. “I have wanted - let me admit it frankly - to commit a murder myself. I recognized this as the desire of the artist to express himself! I was, or could be, an artist in crime!” (Christie 256). He thought that his plan was an art form and he wanted to be recognized. The fact that Wargrave thinks that being responsible for the loss of ten lives is an art form leads the audience to believe that Wargrave is insane. After all, he himself says “I've no doubt in my own mind that we have been invited here by a madman – probably a dangerous homicidal lunatic.” (Christie 56). His perceived insanity proves he is unfit to make life and death decisions. As the judge of the island, this further confirms that his justice system is not fair because he cannot think or judge the circumstances clearly. ( insert quote and supporting evidence

Get Access