preview

Main Characters In Homer's Odyssey And Virgil's Aeneid

Good Essays

[insert title]
In both Homer’s Odyssey and Virgil’s Aeneid, the main characters of each poem, Odysseus and Aeneas, travel to the underworld in search of guidance and the foretelling of fate. In the Odyssey, this scene is being retold by Odysseus to the Phaiakians, while in the Aeneid, the reader is told the scene from a third person point of view. Each poet’s depiction of the underworld has different purposes within the text. I argue that Homer’s depiction is meant for Odysseus to entertain the Phaiakians, while Virgil’s depiction is meant to instate values within Aeneas. Although both texts contain many of the same scenes within the underworld, the differing methods of narration between the texts, and the added details within the Aeneid, greatly change the effects of the scene on characters within the poems. These differences are important because Odysseus must gain favor from the Phaiakians, and Aeneas must fulfill his destiny. To support this argument, I will first discuss each character’s journey in the underworld, the descriptions of the underworld, and finally the purpose within each text.
On each character’s journey to and through the underworld, they go seeking one person but have other experiences that shape the characters and their future journey. Odysseus has been instructed by Circe to seek Tiresias, and Aeneas was visited by his father in a dream and ordered to see him in the underworld. Early in the journey for both characters, they encounter an issue with the unburied dead. Aeneas is told by Sibyl that “a friend lies dead… bear him first to his place of rest” (Virgil, Book 6, Line 179-182) before heading to the underworld. This shows the importance of burying the dead and this is one of the earliest values that Aeneas learns on his journey. Aeneas must protect and respect his men, even in their deaths. The first soul that Odysseus encounters in the underworld is that of Elpenor, his dead companion that “had not yet been buried under earth of the wide ways” (Homer, Book 11, Line 52). Elpenor begs Odysseus to “burn me there with all my armor that belongs to me,” and to give him a proper grave (H, B11, L74). Odysseus later grants Elpenor’s wishes and returns to Aeaea to give him a

Get Access