preview

Malcolm Gladwell's Outliers

Decent Essays

In Malcolm Gladwell's Outliers he argues that outliers, people who have achieved success almost entirely by their own means through perseverance and hard work, are not possible. Gladwell claims instead that people achieve success primarily through the opportunities they are born with or are presented with throughout their life.
While I definitely agree with this claim, I was disappointed by Gladwell's exceedingly fallacious reasoning. In Outliers Gladwell often cherry-picks only information that reinforces his thesis, uses generalization, and is very narrow-minded when it comes to his idea of what “success” is. Throughout the book, cherry-picking information is one of the most obvious problems, Gladwell seems to only use information …show more content…

Throughout the book, Gladwell makes sweeping generalizations about certain races and ethnic groups, often treating stereotypes as though they were proven facts. For example, in chapter eight Gladwell claims that Asian people are more hard working than other cultures because rice fields are much harder to maintain than other kinds of crops, and therefore hard work and dedication is a deep-rooted part of the Asian culture. The problem with this is that Gladwell never provides the reader with evidence that Asian people are any more hard-working than people of any other culture, and instead, treats what is essentially a cultural stereotype as though it was well known scientific fact. Additionally, Gladwell says that “people of Asian background get offended when their culture is described this way, because they think that the stereotype is being used as a form of disparagement. But a belief in work ought to be a thing of beauty.”. Not only is Gladwell insensitively telling the victims of racism how they should feel about stereotypes, but he is also outright admitting that the belief that Asian people are hard workers is just a

Get Access