preview

Manipulating The Sacred : Image And Plague In Renaissance Italy

Decent Essays

Louise Marshall argues in her article Manipulating the Sacred: Image and Plague in Renaissance Italy that art created as a response to the Black Death gives researchers a direct access to the perceptions of the public in regards to surviving the outbreak and how they believed they could “articulate and manipulate their situation” during the plague, and after it. She focuses on the art through the relationship between the individual worshipper and the image. Using images of saints such as Saint Sebastian and the Virgin Mary, the art can be seen as not only an indicator of religious devotion during a dire time or as a record of that particular time’s artistic style, but also as a conversation between the people and the saint that was, in a way, supported and permitted by the Church. Marshall gives an interesting perspective into how the public viewed the art; showing the attitudes in relation to the pestilence as well as the idea of art as a form of propaganda towards which saints would be the best to pray to for mercy and aid. However, if Marshall is correct about how these images operated for the public, then the public were able to have some influence over their situation and the images could also be seen as messages of hope. The idea that an image can be transformed or adapted into any situation is, while believable, still a confusing practice. The Church developed the image of the Virgin Mary as motherly and pure. Changing her image to emphasize attributes of authority and autonomy also changes how the Church would act and worship her. Would this change the foundation of the Church’s saintly principles? Wouldn’t changing the background and characteristics of a religious deity also affect the foundations of the Church’s support? Marshall has successfully achieved the purpose of the article in demonstrating the relevance of art as a historical source of the Black Death but also to psychological effects on the public.
Chapter three in Medieval Death: Ritual and Representation, “The Macabre” by Paul Binski addressed the contrast between the culture of the north and of Italy. Binski examines Christian attitudes towards the dead, their view of corpses, burial rituals and mortuary practices using archaeological

Get Access