preview

Mercury Accumulations

Better Essays

Review of an Engineering and/or Scientific Research paper Title: Historical Atmospheric Mercury Emissions And Depositions in North America Compared to Mercury Accumulations in Sedimentary Records. Authors: Nicola Pirrone, Ivo Allegrini, Gerard J. Keeler, Jerome O. Nriagu, Ronald Rossmann, and John A. Robbins. Published in: Atmospheric Environment. How did you "search" this paper? What terms did you use? It was given to me by you in a packet of scientific papers. What is the motivation for this work (both "people problem" and technical problem)? Technical Problem: The author states that there is sufficient information on emissions, chemistry, transport and deposition of mercury in for the environment but not enough on the role of past …show more content…

This paper seeks to test the correlation between the two by comparing cores and historical records. Confirming this decision-making process affects all of the related factors that are connected to the decision. For example, a real-life connection from this paper could be that someone uses a sediment core to decide whether or not a certain toxin caused a historical increase in deaths. This would be by comparing deaths of a certain type by the toxins concentration in the sediments. If the sediments are not an accurate representation of the toxin at this point in time, this would not be …show more content…

Some are and some are not. The uncertainties are accepted as a necessary part of the process and while not all are accounted for, all are acknowledged. What are the paper's contributions to the scientific community? To society as a whole? (author's and your opinion)? This paper concludes that the difference between the Hg anthropogenic use and the Hg sedimentary record can be explained by uncertainties in the equation and therefore confirms the sedimentary record as a reliable source of Hg deposition history. To society as a whole, it confirms processes which define mercury records and laws. What are some future directions for this research (author's and yours, perhaps driven by shortcomings or other critiques)? I would like to see these methods repeated for different areas. It would be interesting to see how different areas compare. Since one source of difference between the two records of Hg is the variation within the lake, it would be good to try and find an average of the lake and compare it against the Hg deposition

Get Access